Game-based economics research explains why we roll the dice on flu shots

7

Injection by Katherine BarkleyWith 41 states having reported widespread and severe outbreaks of flu this season, timely new research sheds light on why less than half of the American population has gotten a flu shot.

Despite widespread knowledge that a vaccine is the best way to reduce the chances of catching and spreading the flu, even three of the four main TODAY show anchors recently admitted they had not gotten a flu shot (until they did so live on the air).

Using an online computer game that simulates the spread of an infectious disease among its players, researchers at Wake Forest University learned more about what motivates people to protect themselves from infection – from the flu to whooping cough.

The study, the first in the economics of disease control using virtual diseases, was conducted by economists Fred Chen, Allin Cottrell and Amanda Griffith, and computer scientist Yue-Ling Wong.

“When it comes to policies for disease control, one size does not fit all. Some people are very risk tolerant and some are super risk averse. Our research shows that to prevent an epidemic, there is a need to tailor a menu of options for different kinds of people,” said Chen, who studies economic epidemiology.

When studying how best to contain epidemics, scientists and policy makers often must make assumptions in mathematical models about how many people will or will not take preventive measures to keep from getting sick. The virtual epidemic experiment allowed first-hand observation about how people really behave when faced with choices about whether or not to self-protect during a widespread occurrence of infection in a community.

Rolling the dice to stay healthy

The multiplayer game simulates an epidemic among the players over several weeks. At the beginning of each day of the game, healthy players have the option to choose, at a cost, a protective action that reduces the likelihood of getting infected.

“We can’t do in real life what we can do in the game,” said Griffith. “We can’t give some people treatment and others not. The game gave us a way to conduct an experiment on behavior that could never be done in real life.”

Because self-protecting involves a cost, players earned the highest number of points by staying healthy and not choosing the preventative measures. At the end of the game, players knew they would receive a gift card with a value equal to the total number of points earned in the game — an incentive to play honestly.

The experiment was conducted twice. In one game, the cost for players to self-protect was low, in the other it was higher. Players in the low cost condition were significantly more likely to make the choice to protect themselves from infection.

“Players were rolling the dice to see if they could stay healthy without paying the costs of protection. But even those players who were more inclined to take risks chose to self-protect the more often they got sick,” Chen said.

The results can be applied to many illnesses from the common cold to sexually transmitted diseases, where there are costs, financial or otherwise, to taking a preventative measure. For example, in the face of an outbreak of flu, preventative costs might include a fear of negative side effects from taking a vaccination, a fear of needles, lost pay for time away from work, the gas cost of driving to a flu shot center and the time spent waiting in line for a vaccination as well as, for some, the cost of the vaccination itself.

Successfully promoting preventative measures

The study shows that to reduce disease prevalence, policies that reduce the cost of self-protection can be helpful, such as offering paid time off for employees who get flu shots or providing free flu shots onsite.

The research also showed that as the number of players infected increased, so, too, did the number of players who chose to protect themselves from infection.

“At the start of each day, participants could see how many players in the game were infected. As the number of sick players increased, more healthy players chose to take the preventative measure. During a bad cold and flu season like the one we are in this winter, more people may may be willing to take extra precautions if they know how many people in their community are sick,” Chen said.

Researchers also found that players who got infected at a higher rate were more likely to take precautionary action in the future and that people’s willingness to engage in safe behavior increases or decreases over time depending on the seriousness of the epidemic.

Share.
  • http://www.facebook.com/johnbretthauer John Bretthauer

    The reason I don’t get a flu shot is lack of trust in “science.” The first thing that comes to mind is the “food pyramid.” I prefer to call it the Wheat Pyramid. Or how about the low fat diet craze that substituted sugar for fat to dupe people into paying a premium for low fat snacks. Or what about the millions of unnecessary prescriptions for antibiotics that are leaving us with no real defense against super bugs. I just don’t trust that they aren’t screwing up in some way. This is an optional dose when you are already well. I would take the risk of medical intervention if my life was already at risk. I wonder if they are doing more harm than good and that they might find out later that you are better off letting your immune system get stronger by coping with the natural insult of the flu. Maybe I’m misguided.

    • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=654785006 Roy Jones

      You’re confusing a lot of unrelated things here, some of which have more to do with marketing than science or medicine. The real question you need to focus on is whether the influenza vaccine is safe and effective and whether it’s a good choice for you.

  • http://twitter.com/DokktorPropagan Dokktor Propagansett

    Just remember as this “flu scare” is hyped
    through the media that flu shots do not prevent the flu. Beer does. Beer
    & Whiskey. So drink well friends and stay healthy. Don’t let the
    flu fear creep in.

  • TRotRomRee

    Sounds like a pretty solid plan to me dude.

    AnonDot.tk

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1186309798 Brandon McNaughton

    The one time I got a flu shot I got super duper sick… Since then I’ve not gotten any kind of shot or vaccine, and I’ve not been anywhere near that ill

  • Rémi

    One word for you guys: Polio :)

  • http://www.facebook.com/geoff.glave Geoff Glave

    My favourite quote about vaccination: “Not vaccinating your children because you’re afraid of the risk is equivalent to making them play in traffic because you’re worried an airplane might crash on them in the backyard.”