Subscribe
The latest psychology and neuroscience discoveries.
My Account
  • Mental Health
  • Social Psychology
  • Cognitive Science
  • Psychopharmacology
  • Neuroscience
  • About
No Result
View All Result
PsyPost
PsyPost
No Result
View All Result
Home Exclusive Social Psychology

Economic scarcity can invigorate racial stereotypes and even alter our mental representations of Black individuals

by Eric W. Dolan
October 15, 2022
in Social Psychology
(Photo credit: Adobe Stock)

(Photo credit: Adobe Stock)

Share on TwitterShare on Facebook
Don't miss out! Follow PsyPost on Bluesky!

New research provides evidence that racial stereotypes tend to be strengthened under conditions of scarcity. The findings, published in the Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, indicate that economic scarcity can influence mental representations of Black people.

Previous research has indicated that when jobs are few and competition is high, people are more likely to view others in terms of race, seeing members of their own group as more deserving of scarce resources. This could lead to increased tension and conflict between different racial groups. But little is known about the psychological mechanisms driving this effect.

“I became very interested in this topic because it offers a unique perspective on a pervasive social issue — the amplification of racial disparities under times of economic recession,” said study author Michael M. Berkebile-Weinberg, a PhD student in social psychology at New York University.

“This phenomenon is multi-faceted, and this work in particular tries to understand how we as individuals are both impacted by and help propagate systemic forces. That interplay between the individual and the systems that operate in society is a fundamental aspect of intergroup social cognition, and a driving theme in our research going forward.”

In a study of 165 mostly White participants, the researchers used a money allocation game to manipulate perceived scarcity. The participants were informed that they would be given a sum of money, and would then choose how much to allocate to their partner. They were told the endowment size would be determined randomly, but in reality the sum of money was fixed.

In the scarcity condition, the participants were told they had only been given $10 out of a possible $100. In the control condition, they were told they had been given $10 out of a possible $10.

When participants were led to believe that resources were scarce, they were more likely to report having knowledge of stereotypes of Black Americans as low in socioeconomic status and as threatening (e.g. uneducated and aggressive) compared to those in the control group. But scarcity had no impact on stereotypes of White American.

In two additional studies, which included nearly 500 non-Black participants, the researchers used what is known as a reverse correlation procedure to examine visualizations of a Black male face.

In this task, the participants were presented with 200 pairs of faces that were overlaid with different patterns of visual noise, which subtly distorted the image to produce unique facial features. They were then asked which face, out of each pair, depicted a Black person. The images selected as “Black” on each trial were averaged to create a composite image that represented the mental representation of a Black person.

Berkebile and his colleagues found that visualizations of Black faces produced under perceived scarcity appeared more threatening and lower in socioeconomic status compared with a control condition, suggesting that “scarcity leads perceivers to form more stereotypical mental representations of Black people.” Visualizations of Black faces produced under perceived scarcity were also evaluated less positively by a group of independent raters.

“I think the fundamental take-away from this work is that threats in our environment (like signals of economic recession) can fundamentally impact the stereotypes that we hold,” Berkebile told PsyPost. “Further, this extends past just what we think of each other, to affect how we actually see each other, making this process really difficult to control.”

The researchers third study also included an implicit association test, which is often used to measure unconscious racial bias. The test works by measuring the respondent’s reaction time to certain words or images.

Participants with stronger implicit racial bias tended to visualize Black individuals’ faces in a more stereotypical manner, and this was not significantly impacted by perceived scarcity. But among participants with relatively weak implicit racial bias, perceived scarcity appeared to result in a substantial increase in stereotypical visualizations.

“We found an interesting and very surprising effect in the last study,” Berkebile explained. “The general effect that we reported before — that economic scarcity increased stereotyping — was actually strongest for those with less implicit bias compared to those with more implicit bias. We did not have a strong prediction for this analysis, but were surprised to see that those with less bias were impacted by scarcity the most. This analysis was exploratory, so we should replicate this finding before giving it much weight.”

The study includes some limitations and points to areas for additional research. “All of the studies looked at these processes in a strict Black/White American perspective,” Berkebile said. “Future work should extend beyond these groups and test how such patterns play out for different races and other social categories altogether (like gender, for example). Also, we are yet to test the driving force behind these effects. Future work will dive into the mechanisms here to answer why these patterns emerge.”

The study, “Economic scarcity increases racial stereotyping in beliefs and face representation“, was authored by Michael M. Berkebile-Weinberg, Amy R. Krosch, and David M. Amodio.

TweetSendScanShareSendPinShareShareShareShareShare

RELATED

Do you call your partner your best friend? This study says you’re in the minority
Relationships and Sexual Health

Do you call your partner your best friend? This study says you’re in the minority

May 11, 2025

A large study suggests that most people separate romantic and platonic bonds. While some do see their partner as a best friend, the emotional benefits of doing so vary by age, income, and relationship type.

Read moreDetails
New study sheds light on how personality, power, and identity shape relationship satisfaction
Relationships and Sexual Health

New study sheds light on how personality, power, and identity shape relationship satisfaction

May 9, 2025

Personality traits and perceived power don’t operate the same way in every relationship. A new study suggests that identity and relationship context change how these factors influence satisfaction, challenging long-held assumptions about what makes romantic partnerships work.

Read moreDetails
Narcissism may be fueling political polarization, according to new psychology research
Narcissism

Narcissism may be fueling political polarization, according to new psychology research

May 9, 2025

A new study suggests that narcissistic personality traits—especially feelings of entitlement and antagonism—are strongly linked to political polarization. The findings highlight how psychological tendencies may fuel both loyalty to political in-groups and hostility toward opposing sides.

Read moreDetails
Scientists studied Fox News — here’s what they discovered
Political Psychology

Scientists studied Fox News — here’s what they discovered

May 8, 2025

Fox News, a top-rated cable network since 1996, is known for its conservative commentary and strong influence on public opinion. Researchers have increasingly studied its role in shaping Americans’ views on politics, science, and conspiracy theories.

Read moreDetails
Children’s facial expressions reveal fear response to gender-nonconforming boys, study finds
Social Psychology

Children’s facial expressions reveal fear response to gender-nonconforming boys, study finds

May 8, 2025

A new study using facial recognition software found that children react with subtle fear when shown stories about boys who break gender norms. The findings shed light on early emotional bias against gender-nonconforming peers, especially feminine boys.

Read moreDetails
Online incel forums generate “dark emotional energy” that reinforces toxic group identity
Social Psychology

Online incel forums generate “dark emotional energy” that reinforces toxic group identity

May 8, 2025

Online incel communities maintain their cohesion through repeated exchanges of negative emotion, not positive connection. A new study introduces the idea of “dark emotional energy” to explain how despair and rage serve as bonding rituals in these toxic digital spaces.

Read moreDetails
Neuroscientists uncover a fascinating fact about social thinking in the brain
Cognitive Science

Neuroscientists uncover a fascinating fact about social thinking in the brain

May 7, 2025

Our brains process social similarity in two ways—by comparing people to each other and by comparing them to ourselves. A new study using brain imaging reveals that these forms of person knowledge are represented in separate areas of the brain.

Read moreDetails
Women underestimate their spatial intelligence—even when they perform just as well as men
Cognitive Science

Women underestimate their spatial intelligence—even when they perform just as well as men

May 6, 2025

New research shows women underestimate their spatial intelligence, even when they perform just as well as men. This gender gap in self-perception—shaped by personality traits like narcissism and modesty—could help explain why fewer women pursue STEM careers.

Read moreDetails

SUBSCRIBE

Go Ad-Free! Click here to subscribe to PsyPost and support independent science journalism!

STAY CONNECTED

LATEST

Cannabidiol boosts social learning by enhancing brain acetylcholine signaling, study finds

New psychology research explores the costs and benefits of consenting to unwanted sex

Do you call your partner your best friend? This study says you’re in the minority

11 fascinating studies that reveal how motherhood shapes minds, bodies, and brains

Brain rhythms tied to social anxiety may explain why mistakes linger in memory

Common antidepressant may increase pain sensitivity later in life if taken during adolescence

Maternal warmth in childhood predicts key personality traits years later

Psilocybin use has surged in the United States since 2019

         
       
  • Contact us
  • Privacy policy
  • Terms and Conditions
[Do not sell my information]

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist

Subscribe
  • My Account
  • Cognitive Science Research
  • Mental Health Research
  • Social Psychology Research
  • Drug Research
  • Relationship Research
  • About PsyPost
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy