Subscribe
The latest psychology and neuroscience discoveries.
My Account
  • Mental Health
  • Social Psychology
  • Cognitive Science
  • Psychopharmacology
  • Neuroscience
  • About
No Result
View All Result
PsyPost
PsyPost
No Result
View All Result
Home Exclusive Social Psychology

Gratitude buffers threats of male privilege salience, study finds

by Mane Kara-Yakoubian
March 13, 2023
in Social Psychology
Share on TwitterShare on Facebook
Stay on top of the latest psychology findings: Subscribe now!

A brief report published in the journal Psychology of Men & Masculinities examined the role of gratitude in mitigating the adverse well-being effects associated with salient male privilege, such as feeling like an imposter. The researchers found that gratitude served as a buffer for men, neutralizing the threat of privilege salience.

“In the spirit of trying to do courses on topics that ‘matter’ (like my other offerings about death, religion, good, and evil), I first offered a 4th-year seminar on the psychology of men in the Winter 2021 term. Connery Knox – my student-turned-coauthor – submitted a final paper that raised the possibility that drawing attention to gender-based privilege could undermine men’s sense of personal well-being by stirring up impostor-type feelings. I recalled that Branscombe (1998) showed that salient gender-related privilege can undercut men’s collective well-being – that is, their sense of connection with men as a group – as well,” said Christopher T. Burris, a professor of psychology at the St. Jerome’s University within the University of Waterloo.

“Given that most people aren’t in the space to have constructive, good-faith dialogue about sensitive issues when they’re feeling threatened, I wondered whether there was a simple way to blunt the negative personal and collective impacts of gender-related privilege salience on men,” he explained.

“I remembered Barack Obama’s ‘You didn’t build that’ speech in which he tried to make the point that not one of us is 100% responsible for the good things in our lives: We’ve all had help from someone else. As it turned out, reflecting on help from others beforehand indeed appeared to ‘take the teeth out of’ privilege salience among men in a way that being reminded of positive outcomes resulting from chance or one’s own efforts did not.”

Male privilege refers to “unearned societal benefits based on gender.” Awareness of this phenomenon is associated with greater understanding of gender-related issues and less support for hegemonic masculinity. Prior research has suggested that salient male privilege can motivate men to distance themselves from other men and experience lower self-esteem. This could perhaps be explained by the perceived illegitimacy of their ingroup’s benefits as well as feeling like an imposter.

Could gratitude – a reflective experience that is interpersonal in its nature – neutralize the adverse effects of salient gender-based privilege among men? Burris and Knox sought to answer this question.

A total of 245 undergraduate men were assigned to one of six combinations of benefit and male privilege salience reflection tasks. Three of these conditions were combinations of privilege and no gratitude, two were interpersonally focused (gratitude) conditions, and one was a neutral baseline that did not have a benefit or privilege salience reflection task.

In the privilege task, participants were prompted to list the three most significant ways their gender provided them with an advantage. Before this, participants who were assigned to a condition other than “no reflection” or “privilege only” were prompted to reflect on a specific episode in which something good happened, and it was clear that this outcome came to be because of [their own efforts/circumstances/efforts of one or more others], and why [their own efforts made this happen/what happened/who made it happen] and the feelings that emerged as a result.

Afterwards, participants completed measures of gender group identification, self-esteem, imposter-related feelings, positive (e.g., hopeful, confident) and negative (e.g., powerless, ashamed) emotions, gratitude, and provided demographic information. Participants were then asked to describe an unrelated positive experience to offset any adverse effects of privilege salience.

Burris and Knox found that the privilege and no gratitude combinations were associated with higher imposter feelings and lower gender group identification compared to the no-reflection condition; in contrast, gratitude condition participants’ scores on these variables didn’t differ from those of control condition participants. Thus, when salient male privilege was not buffered by gratitude, it led to lower gender group identification and higher imposter feelings among men, even if they had reflected beforehand on positive outcomes that stemmed from their own efforts or circumstances.

“Without a doubt, serious conversations about privilege are worth having, but most people aren’t in the space to engage in constructive, good-faith dialogue about sensitive issues when they’re feeling threatened. Reflecting on the good things in one’s life that are only there because of someone else – things that may have nothing to do with privilege – helps to defuse threat, and therefore *may* help those who are privileged in any context to be more engaged and empathic listeners. We suspect that’s when the most productive conversations will happen,” Burris told PsyPost.

Are there questions that still need answers?

Burris said that “we’ve shown that focusing on other-provided benefits reduces some of the negative personal and collective well-being impacts of gender-based privilege salience in men. Whether that indeed allows men to be more open to difficult conversations about privilege – and to show meaningful attitude and behavior shifts as a result – remains to be tested.”

“The emotion most closely linked to a focus on other-provided benefits is gratitude, but this focus had a positive impact in our study even when the conscious experience of gratitude was no higher on average than it was in our comparison conditions. This raises the question of what specific mechanism is helping to reduce men’s sense of threat in response to salient gender-related privilege. We suspect that it may center on the story people are telling themselves about other-provided benefits: ‘Somebody did something nice for me, so I must have value.’”

The paper, “Gratitude Reduces the Adverse Impact of Salient Male Privilege on Men’s Well-Being”, was authored by Christopher T. Burris and Connery Knox.

TweetSendScanShareSendPin1ShareShareShareShareShare

RELATED

Do you call your partner your best friend? This study says you’re in the minority
Relationships and Sexual Health

Do you call your partner your best friend? This study says you’re in the minority

May 11, 2025

A large study suggests that most people separate romantic and platonic bonds. While some do see their partner as a best friend, the emotional benefits of doing so vary by age, income, and relationship type.

Read moreDetails
New study sheds light on how personality, power, and identity shape relationship satisfaction
Relationships and Sexual Health

New study sheds light on how personality, power, and identity shape relationship satisfaction

May 9, 2025

Personality traits and perceived power don’t operate the same way in every relationship. A new study suggests that identity and relationship context change how these factors influence satisfaction, challenging long-held assumptions about what makes romantic partnerships work.

Read moreDetails
Narcissism may be fueling political polarization, according to new psychology research
Narcissism

Narcissism may be fueling political polarization, according to new psychology research

May 9, 2025

A new study suggests that narcissistic personality traits—especially feelings of entitlement and antagonism—are strongly linked to political polarization. The findings highlight how psychological tendencies may fuel both loyalty to political in-groups and hostility toward opposing sides.

Read moreDetails
Scientists studied Fox News — here’s what they discovered
Political Psychology

Scientists studied Fox News — here’s what they discovered

May 8, 2025

Fox News, a top-rated cable network since 1996, is known for its conservative commentary and strong influence on public opinion. Researchers have increasingly studied its role in shaping Americans’ views on politics, science, and conspiracy theories.

Read moreDetails
Children’s facial expressions reveal fear response to gender-nonconforming boys, study finds
Social Psychology

Children’s facial expressions reveal fear response to gender-nonconforming boys, study finds

May 8, 2025

A new study using facial recognition software found that children react with subtle fear when shown stories about boys who break gender norms. The findings shed light on early emotional bias against gender-nonconforming peers, especially feminine boys.

Read moreDetails
Online incel forums generate “dark emotional energy” that reinforces toxic group identity
Social Psychology

Online incel forums generate “dark emotional energy” that reinforces toxic group identity

May 8, 2025

Online incel communities maintain their cohesion through repeated exchanges of negative emotion, not positive connection. A new study introduces the idea of “dark emotional energy” to explain how despair and rage serve as bonding rituals in these toxic digital spaces.

Read moreDetails
Neuroscientists uncover a fascinating fact about social thinking in the brain
Cognitive Science

Neuroscientists uncover a fascinating fact about social thinking in the brain

May 7, 2025

Our brains process social similarity in two ways—by comparing people to each other and by comparing them to ourselves. A new study using brain imaging reveals that these forms of person knowledge are represented in separate areas of the brain.

Read moreDetails
Women underestimate their spatial intelligence—even when they perform just as well as men
Cognitive Science

Women underestimate their spatial intelligence—even when they perform just as well as men

May 6, 2025

New research shows women underestimate their spatial intelligence, even when they perform just as well as men. This gender gap in self-perception—shaped by personality traits like narcissism and modesty—could help explain why fewer women pursue STEM careers.

Read moreDetails

SUBSCRIBE

Go Ad-Free! Click here to subscribe to PsyPost and support independent science journalism!

STAY CONNECTED

LATEST

Cannabidiol boosts social learning by enhancing brain acetylcholine signaling, study finds

New psychology research explores the costs and benefits of consenting to unwanted sex

Do you call your partner your best friend? This study says you’re in the minority

11 fascinating studies that reveal how motherhood shapes minds, bodies, and brains

Brain rhythms tied to social anxiety may explain why mistakes linger in memory

Common antidepressant may increase pain sensitivity later in life if taken during adolescence

Maternal warmth in childhood predicts key personality traits years later

Psilocybin use has surged in the United States since 2019

         
       
  • Contact us
  • Privacy policy
  • Terms and Conditions
[Do not sell my information]

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist

Subscribe
  • My Account
  • Cognitive Science Research
  • Mental Health Research
  • Social Psychology Research
  • Drug Research
  • Relationship Research
  • About PsyPost
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy