Subscribe
The latest psychology and neuroscience discoveries.
My Account
  • Mental Health
  • Social Psychology
  • Cognitive Science
  • Psychopharmacology
  • Neuroscience
  • About
No Result
View All Result
PsyPost
PsyPost
No Result
View All Result
Home Exclusive Social Psychology Political Psychology

Study uncovers a political stereotype that Democrats are more compassionate than Republicans

New findings provide insight into political polarization in the United States

by Beth Ellwood
January 27, 2021
in Political Psychology
Democrat Joe Biden speaking at the Moving America Forward Forum in 2020. (Photo credit: Gage Skidmore)

Democrat Joe Biden speaking at the Moving America Forward Forum in 2020. (Photo credit: Gage Skidmore)

Share on TwitterShare on Facebook
Stay on top of the latest psychology findings: Subscribe now!

New research published in the journal Emotion offers evidence of a prevailing stereotype that Democrats are more compassionate than Republicans. Their findings further suggest that Democrats exaggerate these differences more strongly than Republicans.

“There has been plenty of press coverage on the growing political polarization in the United States. People appear increasingly hostile and less likely to want to engage socially with their ideological opponents. We wondered whether people might misrepresent the characteristics of their typical ideological outgroup member on an important moral emotion – compassion,” said study author Julian A. Scheffer, a PhD candidate and member of the Empathy and Moral Psychology (EMP) Lab at Pennsylvania State University.

Compassion is a theme that comes up frequently in the discussion of American politics. “For example,” Scheffer and his colleagues wrote in their study, “debate around immigration policy seems to stem in part from Democrats characterizing Republicans as being “cold-hearted” for trying to hinder immigration from war-torn areas, and from Republicans characterizing Democrats as “bleeding-hearts” who allow their emotions to blind them into supporting the immigration of perceived outside threats.”

And still, it is unclear whether the proclaimed differences in compassion between Democrats and Republicans are real or whether they are exaggerated by a stereotype. As Scheffer and his colleagues say, these types of misconceptions are harmful because they increase the separation between political parties and may hinder cooperation between groups.

In a series of five studies, the researchers asked respondents to rate “the average Democrat” and “the average Republican” when it comes to compassion. They then had subjects rate their own levels of compassion. The researchers next analyzed the data to see if a stereotype would be revealed where respondents exaggerated the differences in compassion between Democrats and Republicans, when compared to actual group differences in compassion.

The first three studies were conducted among online samples of American adults recruited in 2015 and showed a similar pattern of findings. Overall, participants consistently rated the average Democrat as more compassionate than the average Republican, suggesting a stereotype was in play.

This stereotype did not match up to respondents’ self-reported compassion — there was no consistent difference between the two groups when it came to their compassion self-ratings. This suggests that the stereotype may not reflect actual differences in compassion.

Notably, the findings also revealed that Democrat respondents were more likely to show this stereotype exaggeration than Republican respondents.

The researchers then conducted two field studies to see if these results would be replicated among a more politically-active sample. These studies were conducted among Iowa voters during the 2016 Caucus and Pennsylvania voters during the U.S. Presidential Election.

Again, the same stereotype surfaced, with Democrats being rated as more compassionate compared to Republicans. And, once more, Democrat respondents were found to exaggerate the extent that the average Democrat is more compassionate than the average Republican.

However, a new finding also emerged. This time, Republicans exaggerated the extent that Democrats were less compassionate than the average Republican. In the field sample, then, supporters of either party appeared to show stereotype exaggeration that worked in the favor of their own political party. The researchers propose that this could be because the field samples were politically-engaged and may have felt more compelled to protect their own group.

“Overall, participants stereotyped the average Democrat/liberal as more compassionate than the average Republican/conservative, but these stereotypes exaggerated group differences on the self-report measure. If people knew that their ideological outgroups were not as different from them as they perceive, then they may be more willing to understand their views, which may be guided by the same moral emotions as their own,” Scheffer told PsyPost.

The researchers acknowledge that the field studies were collected amid a particular political climate and the findings may not generalize to other political contexts.

“We recognize that the current political climate has drastically evolved from 2016 when this work was conducted, so there may be limitations to how well we can generalize these findings to the present,” Scheffer said.

“We also assessed compassion using self-report rather than measuring compassionate responses towards specific targets that may have political relevance. Lastly, it remains an open question of whether these misperceptions lead to intolerance of political outgroups, and whether highlighting that these misperceptions exaggerate reality would help alleviate this intolerance.”

Still, the research offers intriguing preliminary findings.

“During this politically tense period, we think this work provides some context for how people may have become so divided over time,” Scheffer explained. “If people learn that their political outgroups are more like themselves than once thought, it may lead to more effective intergroup dialogue. Otherwise, like the growing polarization over the past few decades, these exaggerations may ultimately fester over time.”

The study, “Stereotypes about Compassion Across the Political Spectrum”, Julian A. Scheffer, C. Daryl Cameron, Stephanie McKee, Eliana Hadjiandreou, and Aaron Scherer.

TweetSendScanShareSendPinShareShareShareShareShare

RELATED

New research shows the psychological toll of the 2024 presidential election
Anxiety

New research shows the psychological toll of the 2024 presidential election

July 13, 2025

Among young adults, stress from election news was linked to higher risks of depression and anxiety, while pre-election anticipatory stress was linked to depression only. Stress about the election outcome was not associated with either condition.

Read moreDetails
Liberals and conservatives live differently — but people think the divide is even bigger than it is
Political Psychology

Liberals and conservatives live differently — but people think the divide is even bigger than it is

July 12, 2025

New research finds that students with different political identities tend to engage in slightly different everyday behaviors. But students dramatically overestimate how much liberals and conservatives differ, fueling a distorted sense of social and political division.

Read moreDetails
Testosterone shifts political preferences in weakly affiliated Democratic men, study finds
Political Psychology

Testosterone shifts political preferences in weakly affiliated Democratic men, study finds

July 10, 2025

What if the key to swaying a swing voter lies in their biology? New research found giving testosterone to weakly affiliated Democratic men made them less loyal to their party and more open to Republicans, revealing a potential hormonal link to political persuasion.

Read moreDetails
People with psychopathic traits fail to learn from painful outcomes
Narcissism

National narcissism linked to emotional impairments and dehumanization, new study finds

July 7, 2025

A new study suggests that people who see their nation as uniquely important often struggle with recognizing emotions and experience more anger and contempt—factors that may help explain why they’re more likely to dehumanize both outsiders and fellow citizens.

Read moreDetails
Fascinating study reveals how Trump’s moral rhetoric diverges from common Republican language
Donald Trump

Viral AI-images highlight how Trump engages in “victimcould,” scholar argues

July 6, 2025

How can one of the world's most powerful men also be its biggest victim? A new paper argues it’s a political strategy based on hypothetical, not actual, harm—a concept the author calls “victimcould” used to justify present-day aggression.

Read moreDetails
New study suggests Donald Trump’s “fake news” attacks are backfiring
Political Psychology

Scientists are uncovering more and more unsettling facts about our politics

July 5, 2025

Why has politics become so personal? The answers may lie in our minds. These 13 studies from the new science of political behavior reveal the hidden psychological forces—from personality to primal fear—that are driving us further apart.

Read moreDetails
These common sounds can impair your learning, according to new psychology research
Political Psychology

Despite political tensions, belief in an impending U.S. civil war remains low

July 4, 2025

A new national survey finds that only a small fraction of Americans believe civil war is likely or necessary.

Read moreDetails
Racial and religious differences help explain why unmarried voters lean Democrat
Political Psychology

Student loan debt doesn’t deter civic engagement — it may actually drive it, new research suggests

July 3, 2025

Americans with student loan debt are more likely to vote and engage in political activities than those without debt, likely because they see government as responsible and capable of addressing their financial burden through policy change.

Read moreDetails

SUBSCRIBE

Go Ad-Free! Click here to subscribe to PsyPost and support independent science journalism!

STAY CONNECTED

LATEST

Narcissistic individuals are more prone to maladaptive daydreaming

Effort or fate? Sexual mindsets predict whether bedroom bliss spills over into broader wellbeing

People who use AI may pay a social price, according to new psychology research

Researchers identify a shared brain pattern behind feeling surprised

New research shows the psychological toll of the 2024 presidential election

Methylphenidate: ADHD drug curbs impulsivity in men only, linked to brain wiring differences

Daughters who feel more attractive report stronger, more protective bonds with their fathers

Brain scans reveal who may benefit most from MDMA for trauma-related symptoms

         
       
  • Contact us
  • Privacy policy
  • Terms and Conditions
[Do not sell my information]

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist

Subscribe
  • My Account
  • Cognitive Science Research
  • Mental Health Research
  • Social Psychology Research
  • Drug Research
  • Relationship Research
  • About PsyPost
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy