Subscribe
The latest psychology and neuroscience discoveries.
My Account
  • Mental Health
  • Social Psychology
  • Cognitive Science
  • Psychopharmacology
  • Neuroscience
  • About
No Result
View All Result
PsyPost
PsyPost
No Result
View All Result
Home Exclusive Social Psychology Political Psychology

Democrats and Republicans see each other as “more stupid than evil,” according to new psychology research

by Eric W. Dolan
February 24, 2022
in Political Psychology
Share on TwitterShare on Facebook
Stay on top of the latest psychology findings: Subscribe now!

Republican and Democratic partisans tend to disparage each other’s intelligence more than each other’s morality, according to new research to be published in Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin. The findings provide new details about political polarization in the United States.

“In recent years, there has been an alarming increase in animosity between political opponents,” said study author Rachel Hartman (@RachelXHartman), a PhD student at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill and member of the Deepest Beliefs Lab and the Center for the Science of Moral Understanding.

“Many researchers have focused on bridging moral divides between liberals and conservatives to reduce feelings of antipathy, but that seems to assume that the conflict is a moral conflict. I felt that that assumption is worth testing. If the conflict isn’t even about morality, then we might be wasting time trying to get people to see past their differences.”

Across four studies, the researchers found that liberals and conservatives both view each other as more unintelligent than immoral.

Hartman and her colleagues first set out to examine whether perceiving one’s political rivals as unintelligent and perceiving one’s political rivals as immoral were two distinct factors. They recruited 481 Americans from Amazon’s Mechanical Turk platform and used a statistical technique known as factor analysis to confirm that this was the case.

Next, Hartman and her colleagues investigated how North Carolinians perceived the unintelligence and immorality of liberals and conservatives shortly after a statewide vote on six amendments to the North Carolina constitution in 2018. In the study, 360 North Carolina residents read the six amendments, and were informed that conservatives generally supported the amendments while liberals generally opposed them. The participants were then asked why liberals and conservatives voted the way they did.

Liberal participants were more likely to perceive conservatives as unintelligent and immoral for supporting the amendments, while conservative participants were more likely to perceive liberals as unintelligent and immoral for opposing the amendments. Importantly, however, both liberals and conservatives rated unintelligence as a greater factor than immorality.

For their third study, the research team surveyed a nationally representative sample of 633 Americans. In line with their previous studies, they found that self-identified Democrats and Republicans rated each other as more unintelligent than immoral. Democrats’ judgments of Republicans tended to be more negative than Republicans’ judgments of Democrats.

Hartman and her colleagues also examined meta-perceptions. In their final study, they recruited 176 Americans from Amazon’s Mechanical Turk and asked them to rate how they thought the average Democrat perceived the average Republican and vice versa. Participants accurately thought that Democrats and Republicans viewed each other as more unintelligent than immoral, but they exaggerated the magnitude of disparagement.

“I want to be careful not to overclaim and draw conclusions beyond what we actually tested. Our main finding is that political opponents see each other as more unintelligent than immoral,” Hartman told PsyPost.

“We don’t have the data yet to support any specific recommendations for how people should change the way they engage with political opponents. But dismissing others as being unintelligent, misinformed, or brainwashed seems demeaning and dehumanizing. When you come across someone on the opposite side of an issue, try to communicate your reasons for holding your belief, and listen when they talk about their own reasons.”

“Very smart people can disagree with each other — that’s often a good thing! Having a well-functioning democracy means having a plurality of ideas that people can come together to discuss civilly,” Hartman added.

Like all research, the study includes some limitations. For example, it is unclear how well the findings generalize to political contexts outside the United States. The researchers also noted that is possible that momentous events, such as the storming of the Capitol on January 6, 2021, could significantly alter people’s political perceptions. Future research is also needed to examine ways to effectively reduce polarization.

“As I alluded to above, we haven’t yet taken the next step of applying this work to interventions for reducing animosity,” Hartman said. “There’s some work from our center suggesting that recognizing that people have good reasons for their beliefs reduces animosity, but we would still like to directly test whether we can change perceptions of intelligence and the extent to which doing so is beneficial. It’s also likely that, while political opponents see each other as more stupid than evil overall, there may be particular issues or contexts where that difference goes away, or is even reversed.”

“As psychologists, our work focuses on a psychological understanding of partisan animosity, and the interventions we work with work at the level of changing the way people think about and interact with each other,” Hartman added. “But partisan animosity is a structural problem, and there’s only so much we can do at the individual level. To enact lasting change, our institutions and media environments need to change as well.”

The study, “People See Political Opponents As More Stupid Than Evil”, was authored by Rachel Hartman, Neil Hester, and Kurt Gray.

TweetSendScanShareSendPin2ShareShareShareShareShare

RELATED

People with psychopathic traits fail to learn from painful outcomes
Narcissism

National narcissism linked to emotional impairments and dehumanization, new study finds

July 7, 2025

A new study suggests that people who see their nation as uniquely important often struggle with recognizing emotions and experience more anger and contempt—factors that may help explain why they’re more likely to dehumanize both outsiders and fellow citizens.

Read moreDetails
Fascinating study reveals how Trump’s moral rhetoric diverges from common Republican language
Donald Trump

Viral AI-images highlight how Trump engages in “victimcould,” scholar argues

July 6, 2025

How can one of the world's most powerful men also be its biggest victim? A new paper argues it’s a political strategy based on hypothetical, not actual, harm—a concept the author calls “victimcould” used to justify present-day aggression.

Read moreDetails
New study suggests Donald Trump’s “fake news” attacks are backfiring
Political Psychology

Scientists are uncovering more and more unsettling facts about our politics

July 5, 2025

Why has politics become so personal? The answers may lie in our minds. These 13 studies from the new science of political behavior reveal the hidden psychological forces—from personality to primal fear—that are driving us further apart.

Read moreDetails
These common sounds can impair your learning, according to new psychology research
Political Psychology

Despite political tensions, belief in an impending U.S. civil war remains low

July 4, 2025

A new national survey finds that only a small fraction of Americans believe civil war is likely or necessary.

Read moreDetails
Racial and religious differences help explain why unmarried voters lean Democrat
Political Psychology

Student loan debt doesn’t deter civic engagement — it may actually drive it, new research suggests

July 3, 2025

Americans with student loan debt are more likely to vote and engage in political activities than those without debt, likely because they see government as responsible and capable of addressing their financial burden through policy change.

Read moreDetails
Scientists just uncovered a surprising illusion in how we remember time
Mental Health

New research suggests the conservative mental health advantage is a myth

July 3, 2025

Do conservatives really have better mental well-being than liberals? A new study suggests the answer depends entirely on how you ask. The well-known ideological gap disappears when "mental health" is replaced with the less-stigmatized phrase "overall mood."

Read moreDetails
New psychology study sheds light on mysterious “feelings of presence” during isolation
Political Psychology

People who think “everyone agrees with me” are more likely to support populism

July 1, 2025

People who wrongly believe that most others share their political views are more likely to support populist ideas, according to a new study. These false beliefs can erode trust in democratic institutions and fuel resentment toward political elites.

Read moreDetails
Radical leaders inspire stronger devotion because they make followers feel significant, study finds
Political Psychology

Radical leaders inspire stronger devotion because they make followers feel significant, study finds

June 28, 2025

A new study finds that voters are more motivated by radical political leaders than moderates, because supporting bold causes makes them feel personally significant—driving greater activism, sacrifice, and long-term engagement across elections in the United States and Poland.

Read moreDetails

SUBSCRIBE

Go Ad-Free! Click here to subscribe to PsyPost and support independent science journalism!

STAY CONNECTED

LATEST

Can sunshine make you happier? A massive study offers a surprising answer

New study links why people use pornography to day-to-day couple behavior

Virtual reality meditation eases caregiver anxiety during pediatric hospital stays, with stronger benefits for Spanish speakers

Fascinating new advances in psychedelic science reveal how they may heal the mind

Dysfunction within the sensory processing cortex of the brain is associated with insomnia, study finds

Prenatal exposure to “forever chemicals” linked to autistic traits in children, study finds

Ketamine repairs reward circuitry to reverse stress-induced anhedonia

Neuroscientists decode how people juggle multiple items in working memory

         
       
  • Contact us
  • Privacy policy
  • Terms and Conditions
[Do not sell my information]

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist

Subscribe
  • My Account
  • Cognitive Science Research
  • Mental Health Research
  • Social Psychology Research
  • Drug Research
  • Relationship Research
  • About PsyPost
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy