PsyPost
  • Mental Health
  • Social Psychology
  • Cognitive Science
  • Neuroscience
  • About
No Result
View All Result
Join
My Account
PsyPost
No Result
View All Result
Home Exclusive Social Psychology Political Psychology

Forbidden knowledge claims polarize beliefs and critical thinking across political lines

by Mane Kara-Yakoubian
December 11, 2024
Reading Time: 3 mins read
[Adobe Stock]

[Adobe Stock]

Research published in the Personality & Social Psychology Bulletin reveals that claims of censorship or “forbidden knowledge” polarize perceptions and critical thinking based on political ideology.

Victoria A. Parker and colleagues explored how censorship claims about controversial topics, such as COVID-19, influence public perceptions. Building on past research into the “forbidden fruit” phenomenon, which suggests that people value restricted information more, the team investigated whether such claims, particularly around politically charged issues, like vaccine risk, might heighten allure or skepticism depending on political alignment.

In Study 1a, the researchers recruited 1,000 participants via Prolific, balancing liberal and conservative self-identifications. Participants were randomly assigned to one of two conditions. In the forbidden condition, participants read three COVID-19-related headlines framed as censored (e.g., “THE TRUTH about the possible lab origins of the COVID-19 virus is being kept from you. Here’s the information NO ONE is allowed to talk about”); the control condition featured neutral framings of the same headlines (e.g., “New reports about the possible risks of mRNA”). The topics included COVID-19’s lab origins, alternative treatments, and vaccine risks. Participants rated their attraction to, belief in, and perceptions of censorship for the headlines on 11-point scales.

Study 1b involved 390 participants, also evenly split by political ideology and recruited through Prolific. Participants were asked to imagine hypothetical censorship scenarios for the same COVID-19 topics. They then rated six questions about their interpretations of censorship, focusing on whether censorship implied the information was harmful or false (a cautionary interpretation) or valuable and suppressed by powerful entities (a reactance interpretation).

Study 2, which included 973 participants recruited from CloudResearch, extended these findings by examining the effects of forbidden knowledge framing on critical thinking. Participants read a fabricated headline about vaccine risks framed either as censored or neutral. They then read a fictitious article describing vaccine risk data, which required calculating proportions to determine that vaccination did not increase the risk of severe symptoms. Participants were asked to draw conclusions from the data. This design tested whether forbidden knowledge framing influenced participants’ ability to critically evaluate worldview-consistent claims.

Study 1a revealed meaningful differences in how liberals and conservatives responded to forbidden knowledge framing. Conservatives consistently rated the forbidden knowledge framed headlines as more censored, attractive, and believable than liberals, regardless of condition. This framing, however, amplified ideological divides: liberals reported less attraction and belief in forbidden knowledge-framed headlines compared to neutrally framed ones, while conservatives maintained high levels of attraction and belief across conditions.

Study 1b demonstrated that liberals and conservatives interpreted censorship claims differently. Liberals generally associated censorship with misinformation, assuming it signaled that the information was harmful or false. Conservatives, in contrast, viewed censorship as evidence of valuable information being suppressed by powerful entities, aligning with a reactance perspective.

Study 2 showed that forbidden knowledge framing significantly influenced conservatives’ critical thinking. Conservatives who read the forbidden knowledge-framed article about vaccine risks were more likely to incorrectly conclude that vaccination increased the risk of severe symptoms. In contrast, conservatives in the neutral condition and liberals in both conditions were more likely to correctly interpret the data, concluding that vaccines did not increase risk.

Combined, these results emphasize how forbidden knowledge framing deepens ideological divides and influences critical thinking processes, in ways that perpetuate polarization.

One limitation is that these studies focused on conservative-aligned COVID-19 claims, limiting the generalizability of findings across other topics.

The research, “Alluring or Alarming? The Polarizing Effect of Forbidden Knowledge in Political Discourse,” was authored by Victoria A. Parker, E. Kehoe, J. Lees, M. Facciani, and A. E. Wilson.

TweetSendScanShareSendPinShareShareShareShareShare

Follow PsyPost

The latest research, however you prefer to read it.

Daily newsletter

One email a day. The newest research, nothing else.

Google News

Get PsyPost stories in your Google News feed.

Add PsyPost to Google News
RSS feed

Use your favorite reader.

Copy RSS URL
Social media
Support independent science journalism

Ad-free reading, full archives, and weekly deep dives for members.

Become a member

Trending

  • Women want to talk about sex with their close friends more often, study finds
  • Scientists uncover how a tiny reflection of light helps us navigate the social world
  • Over 10 percent of factual claims in Google’s AI search summaries aren’t backed by their cited sources, study finds
  • Inflammation briefly dampens pleasure and the desire to socialize, placebo-controlled study finds
  • Narcissistic parents tend to lean on their children for emotional support, and that is linked to depression later on

Science of Money

  • For male startup founders, average looks may pay off best in the pitch room, according to new Shark Tank study
  • Why struggling with bills feels even worse when you think the economy is booming
  • Feeling stuck in an unwanted work location takes a measurable toll on mental health
  • Why having a self-sacrificing boss can feel like a trap, according to psychology
  • News about shortages only triggers stockpiling when shoppers start searching online, study finds

Recent

  • Loving-kindness meditation fails to beat muscle relaxation for pain or social well-being in online trial
  • Losing childhood weight by adulthood might erase later depression risks
  • Women don’t find deeper-than-average voices more attractive when they can see the man
  • Voters value long-term economic growth more than previously thought, study finds
  • Scientists map a blood protein fingerprint of menopause tied to brain health
  • Social anxiety might not warp how we perceive eye contact
  • In female mice modeling schizophrenia, a single dose of psilocybin restored sensory filtering for days
  • Could psychedelics aid therapy for personality disorders? An unusual case offers a first look
  • Schizophrenia is linked to broad difficulty reading emotions from body language and faces
  • Socially isolated and lonely people tend to be biologically older than their years

PsyPost is a psychology and neuroscience news website dedicated to reporting the latest research on human behavior, cognition, and society. (READ MORE...)

  • Mental Health
  • Neuroimaging
  • Personality Psychology
  • Social Psychology
  • Artificial Intelligence
  • Cognitive Science
  • Psychopharmacology
  • Contact us
  • Disclaimer
  • Privacy policy
  • Terms and conditions
  • FAQ

(c) PsyPost Media Inc

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist

Subscribe
  • My Account
  • Cognitive Science Research
  • Mental Health Research
  • Social Psychology Research
  • Drug Research
  • Relationship Research
  • About PsyPost
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy

(c) PsyPost Media Inc