Subscribe
The latest psychology and neuroscience discoveries.
My Account
  • Mental Health
  • Social Psychology
  • Cognitive Science
  • Psychopharmacology
  • Neuroscience
  • About
No Result
View All Result
PsyPost
PsyPost
No Result
View All Result
Home Exclusive Social Psychology Racism and Discrimination

Having a victim mindset is linked to internalizing a vigilante identity

New research explores the psychological connection between interpersonal victimhood and vigilantism

by Vladimir Hedrih
November 5, 2023
in Racism and Discrimination, Social Psychology
Share on TwitterShare on Facebook
Stay on top of the latest psychology findings: Subscribe now!

Individuals who frequently believe they have been victimized in their relationships with others are more likely to develop a vigilante mindset, according to a series of four studies. These studies, published in the journal Personality and Individual Differences, suggest that such individuals are more likely to construct a vigilante identity organized around monitoring their environment looking for signs of wrongdoing and delivering punishment

A vigilante is an individual who takes the law into their own hands and engages in acts of justice or retribution without the authority of law enforcement or the legal system. Vigilantes typically act on their perception of right and wrong and may seek to correct what they perceive as injustices or wrongdoing. While they may have noble intentions, their actions often fall outside the boundaries of the legal system, potentially causing harm, chaos, or further injustices.

New research reported that ordinary citizens sometimes adopt a vigilante identity and proceed to punish those they believe have done something wrong. This happens even though such citizens have no formal authority to deliver punishments and have not received permission to do so. However, it remains unclear what makes one adopt a vigilante identity.

Study author Fan Xuan Chen and his colleagues wanted to examine factors that might make individuals more likely to assume a vigilante identity. They hypothesized that perceiving oneself as a victim in relationships with others might make one more likely to adopt vigilante identity and motivate him/her to look for and correct social norm violations through punishment. To test this, they conducted a series of 4 studies.

The first study surveyed 221 participants from the United States using Amazon’s MTurk platform. The researchers measured participants’ self-identification with a vigilante role using the Vigilante Identity Scale and evaluated the association with their readiness to punish social norm violations. Participants were given a hypothetical scenario involving a professor accused of inappropriate conduct and were then asked if they would publicize or comment on a student’s allegations, actions considered punitive against the professor.

The second study investigated the correlation between self-perceived victimhood, measured by the Tendency for Interpersonal Victimhood Scale, and the adoption of a vigilante identity. This identity was then assessed for its predictive value in determining participants’ propensity to monitor conflict-related behavior on social media. The participants, 541 Canadian university students, were presented with a hypothetical incident of alleged racism at a diner and asked to report their likelihood of tracking the story’s developments online.

In the third study, researchers used an economic game within an experimental setting to determine if those with pronounced vigilante identities were more punitive towards individuals violating norms. The 233 participants, recruited from MTurk, were tasked with deciding on imposing a financial penalty on a coworker depicted as breaching COVID-19 health regulations.

The fourth and final study involved 120 managerial-level employees from a prominent Chinese pharmaceutical company. The aim was to examine whether managers who perceived themselves as victimized in interpersonal relationships—and presumably more inclined towards a vigilante identity—were perceived by their subordinates as more punitive.

The findings from the first study revealed that individuals with a strong vigilante identity were more punitive. The second study supported the notion that individuals who viewed themselves as victims were more likely to embrace a vigilante identity and actively monitor social media for norm violations. The analysis suggested that vigilante identity partly mediated the relationship between self-perceived victimhood and the surveillance of social media for norm violations.

The third study corroborated the association between self-perceived interpersonal victimhood and the adoption of a vigilante identity. Moreover, those with a stronger vigilante identity showed a greater propensity to punish perceived norm violators. The fourth study echoed these findings, illustrating that managers who considered themselves victims were more likely to enforce harsher punishments.

“Our research advances vigilante scholarship by showing that people who tend to perceive themselves as perpetual victims in their interpersonal relationships are more likely to internalize a vigilante identity. In turn, this internalization predicts their willingness to closely monitor the environment for signs of wrongdoing and taking it upon themselves to punish alleged wrongdoers,” the study authors concluded.

The study sheds light on the roots and consequences of vigilantism. However, it also has limitations that need to be considered. Notably, save for the last study, all other punishment and vigilantism scenarios were fictional. No consequences stemmed from decisions participants made and participants were fully aware that the entire situation is hypothetical. Behaviors in real situations might not be the same.

The paper, ”Suffering saviors: Relationships between perceptions of interpersonal victimhood, the vigilante identity, and the monitoring and punishment of norm violators”, was authored by Fan Xuan Chen, Ekin Ok, and Karl Aquino.

TweetSendScanShareSendPin1ShareShareShareShareShare

RELATED

Gynandromorph research offers insight into the complexities of male sexual attraction
Sexism

Eye-tracking study shows people fixate longer on female aggressors than male ones

June 23, 2025

People pay more visual attention to female aggressors than male ones, but do not consistently judge their actions as more intentional or blameworthy, suggesting that female aggression is seen as unexpected rather than more morally significant.

Read moreDetails
Breakups can trigger trauma in emerging adults
Relationships and Sexual Health

Romantic breakups follow a two-stage decline that begins years before the split, study finds

June 23, 2025

A new study shows that romantic relationships often begin to unravel one to two years before they officially end. Researchers found a two-phase pattern of decline in satisfaction that could help identify when relationships are heading for a breakup.

Read moreDetails
It’s not digital illiteracy: Here’s why older adults are drawn to dubious news
Social Media

Believing “news will find me” is linked to sharing fake news, study finds

June 22, 2025

People who rely on social media to “stumble upon” news are more prone to spreading misinformation, according to a new longitudinal study.

Read moreDetails
Political ambivalence has a surprising relationship with support for violence
Authoritarianism

New study sheds light on the psychological roots of collective violence

June 21, 2025

A new study from Lebanon finds that people with authoritarian beliefs tend to oppose violence against political leaders, while those high in social dominance orientation are more likely to support violence against rival group members.

Read moreDetails
Scientists observe reduced emotional distress in children living near greenery
Racism and Discrimination

Adults’ beliefs about children and race shift when a child’s race is specified, study finds

June 21, 2025

Specifying a child’s race alters how adults perceive their awareness of race and racism, according to new research. Black children are viewed as less “color-evasive” and more racially aware at earlier ages than White children or generic “children.”

Read moreDetails
Study helps untangle the complicated relationship between psychopathy and emotional awareness
Psychopathy

Psychopathic individuals recognize unfairness but are less likely to punish it

June 21, 2025

A new study shows that individuals with higher psychopathic traits are less likely to punish unfair behavior, especially when it costs them personally. The research suggests self-interest, not a lack of moral understanding, drives their reluctance to enforce social norms.

Read moreDetails
The neuroscience of why we cry happy tears
Social Psychology

The neuroscience of why we cry happy tears

June 20, 2025

Why do people cry happy tears? Neuroscience suggests these emotional outbursts occur when the brain becomes overwhelmed by joy, nostalgia, or relief. Far from being irrational, crying during joyful moments helps restore balance and deepen human connection.

Read moreDetails
Epistemic mistrust and dogmatism predict preference for authoritarian-looking leaders
Authoritarianism

Epistemic mistrust and dogmatism predict preference for authoritarian-looking leaders

June 20, 2025

A new study suggests that the way people learn to trust others early in life can shape their political ideology and preference for strong, dominant leaders—though not directly, but through dogmatic thinking and broader political attitudes.

Read moreDetails

SUBSCRIBE

Go Ad-Free! Click here to subscribe to PsyPost and support independent science journalism!

STAY CONNECTED

LATEST

Exposure to heavy metals is associated with higher likelihood of ADHD diagnosis

Eye-tracking study shows people fixate longer on female aggressors than male ones

Romantic breakups follow a two-stage decline that begins years before the split, study finds

Believing “news will find me” is linked to sharing fake news, study finds

A common parasite not only invades the brain — it can also decapitate human sperm

Almost all unmarried pregant women say that the fetus resembles the father, study finds

New neuroscience research reveals brain antioxidant deficit in depression

Scientists uncover kidney-to-brain route for Parkinson’s-related protein spread

         
       
  • Contact us
  • Privacy policy
  • Terms and Conditions
[Do not sell my information]

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist

Subscribe
  • My Account
  • Cognitive Science Research
  • Mental Health Research
  • Social Psychology Research
  • Drug Research
  • Relationship Research
  • About PsyPost
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy