A recent study published in Human Brain Mapping provides evidence that young adults experiencing suicidal thoughts process concepts related to death differently in their brains compared to healthy individuals. The findings indicate that these individuals reflexively associate death-related ideas with their own sense of self. This research suggests that brain imaging combined with artificial intelligence could eventually help identify people at risk for suicide based on how their brains represent specific words.
If you or someone you know is experiencing suicidal thoughts or a mental health crisis, help is available. Call or text 988 to reach the free and confidential Suicide & Crisis Lifeline, or chat live at 988lifeline.org.
While mental health professionals typically rely on patients to report their feelings, people at risk for suicide do not always disclose their struggles. Finding an objective physical measurement in the brain could help identify those in need of support.
Previous behavioral tests have indicated that individuals with suicidal thoughts tend to implicitly link themselves with the idea of death. For example, word association games often show that these individuals connect words like “funeral” or “suicide” with words related to themselves. The scientists wanted to see if this psychological link leaves a detectable footprint in the brain.
“Our laboratory’s goal is to understand how thought is underpinned by brain activity. We explored whether certain concepts in people who were thinking about suicide were systematically altered by examining the underlying brain activity,” said study author Marcel Just, D.O. Hebb University Professor at Carnegie Mellon University.
The research team relied on the idea that the human brain functions like a universal concept dictionary. When people think of a common object, like a banana, their brains show very similar patterns of activity. The scientists aimed to determine if the neural blueprint for death-related concepts is uniquely altered in people experiencing suicidal thoughts.
The study included a final sample of 154 young adults between the ages of 18 and 30. Of these participants, 89 were currently experiencing suicidal ideation, and 65 were healthy individuals with no history of mental health conditions. The researchers ensured that the two groups were evenly matched in terms of age, gender ratio, and general intelligence.
To measure brain activity, the scientists used functional magnetic resonance imaging. This is a common brain scanning technique that tracks blood flow to different areas of the brain, revealing which regions are active during a specific task. While inside the scanner, participants were shown a series of 28 words on a screen.
These words were divided into four categories, which included suicide-related concepts, positive concepts, negative concepts, and attitude-related concepts. The suicide-related words included terms like death, funeral, lifeless, and hopeless. Each word appeared on the screen for three seconds, and participants were instructed to actively think about the main properties and meaning of the word.
The words were presented multiple times in different random orders. This repetition allowed the scientists to identify brain voxels, which are tiny three-dimensional units of brain tissue, that consistently responded to the specific concepts. The scientists then analyzed this brain scan data using machine learning, which is a type of computer algorithm designed to recognize complex patterns.
They specifically trained the algorithm to look at areas of the brain that previous studies have linked to thinking about oneself. These self-representation regions include structures like the precuneus and the middle temporal gyrus, which are typically active when people reflect on their own lives or identities.
The machine learning program successfully distinguished the individuals with suicidal thoughts from the healthy participants with a moderate but reliable accuracy of about 57 to 61 percent. This distinction was based entirely on the brain activity observed when participants thought about the suicide-related concepts.
When thinking about words like “death” or “funeral,” the individuals with suicidal thoughts showed distinct activation in the brain regions responsible for self-reflection. This pattern provides evidence that these individuals reflexively think about themselves when processing concepts related to dying.
“Individuals experiencing suicidal ideation associate the ‘self’ with concepts related to death,” Just told PsyPost. “We can now detect these neural signatures using fMRI.”
The researchers also tested the other categories of words, including the positive and negative terms. The brain activity associated with these non-suicide-related words did not distinguish the two groups above random chance. This specificity suggests that the altered brain patterns are strictly tied to how the individuals perceive death, rather than a general difference in how they process all emotional words.
The scientists noted that the algorithm could distinguish the groups even when the analysis was restricted to just two words, which were death and funeral. They also mathematically controlled for differences in age, intelligence, and data quality to ensure the algorithm was truly detecting the mental link to death. By identifying this specific conceptual alteration, the study establishes a measurable neurobiological basis for suicidal ideation.
“It is technically possible to use neuroimaging to determine if a person’s representation of death-related concepts is unusually linked to their ‘self-representation,'” Just explained. “This determination can potentially be made even if the person does not verbally disclose those thoughts.”
“Perhaps the most profound implication is that, to a first order, everyone with a healthy brain represents concepts similarly. Whether it is a ‘cup’ or a ‘banana,’ the neural machinery is consistent across the species. This ‘universal concept dictionary’ of the brain is what allows us to analyze activity and determine what a person is thinking—a process the media often calls ‘mindreading.'”
While these findings are promising, there are some limitations and potential misinterpretations to keep in mind. The current accuracy rate of the algorithm is too low for this test to be used as a standalone clinical diagnostic tool right now. The test correctly identified many individuals with suicidal thoughts, but it also produced a notable number of false positives and false negatives.
Additionally, the scanning process requires intense focus, and the researchers had to exclude data from 77 other initial participants who let their minds wander during the lengthy twenty-five-minute task. “Performing a scan of brain activity in an MRI scanner is cumbersome and requires the use of a very expensive instrument,” Just noted. “So using this method to detect suicidal ideation is not currently practical for routine clinical screening.”
In the future, the research team hopes to refine this procedure to make it shorter and easier for participants to complete. A shorter task focusing only on a few highly informative words might improve the quality of the data and the accuracy of the algorithm. The scientists also plan to adapt this method for use with less expensive and more accessible technologies.
For instance, translating this approach to electroencephalography, a method that measures electrical brain waves using a cap of sensors, could make the test widely available in standard clinics. Ultimately, developing therapies that help break the mental link between the self and death could provide a new pathway to support those at risk for suicide.
The study, “Neural Representations of Death-Related Concepts Identify Conceptual Alteration of Self in Suicidal Youth,” was authored by Marcel Adam Just, Robert Mason, Lisa Pan, Dana McMakin, Christine Cha, Matthew K. Nock, and David Brent.
