Subscribe
The latest psychology and neuroscience discoveries.
My Account
  • Mental Health
  • Social Psychology
  • Cognitive Science
  • Psychopharmacology
  • Neuroscience
  • About
No Result
View All Result
PsyPost
PsyPost
No Result
View All Result
Home Exclusive Social Psychology Business

Managers tend to target loyal workers for exploitation, study finds

by Vladimir Hedrih
April 5, 2024
in Business
(Photo credit: Adobe Stock)

(Photo credit: Adobe Stock)

Share on TwitterShare on Facebook
Stay informed on the latest psychology and neuroscience research—follow PsyPost on LinkedIn for daily updates and insights.

A series of online studies discovered that full-time managers often exploit loyal workers rather than protect and reward them. This exploitation includes assigning additional unpaid work or uncomfortable tasks outside work hours, under the assumption that loyal employees are willing to make personal sacrifices for their company. This research was published in the Journal of Experimental Social Psychology.

Loyalty is a virtue that involves a strong sense of commitment, allegiance, or fidelity to a person, group, or cause. It is important because it fosters trust and stability in relationships, whether personal, professional, or societal. Loyalty builds confidence and reliability, as individuals know they can depend on each other in times of need or adversity.

In the workplace, loyalty contributes to a positive and cohesive work environment, leading to increased productivity and job satisfaction. In personal relationships, loyalty strengthens bonds and creates a sense of security and mutual respect. Multiple theories see loyalty as one of the key foundations of morality, binding groups together, making them more cohesive and coordinated in ways that usually make the groups more successful.

But is loyalty always beneficial for the loyal person? Study author Matthew L. Stanley and his colleagues wanted to explore this by investigating the relationships between managers and employees. They were particularly interested in the relationships between perceived loyalty and exploitative organizational practices, which often involve assigning excessive or unrelated tasks without additional compensation, benefitting managers at the expense of employees.

The researchers hypothesized that managers might view loyal employees as more exploitable, targeting them for exploitation. Alternatively, they considered whether managers might protect loyal workers to retain their allegiance. Four studies were conducted with participants ranging from 211 to 510 full-time managers, recruited via Prolific.

In the first study, managers were split into three groups, with the first group reading about a loyal employee named John. The survey then described scenarios requiring someone to work overtime or perform uncomfortable tasks without compensation, querying the likelihood of assigning John to these tasks. The second and third groups underwent similar procedures, but with John described as either disloyal or without any characterization. All participants assessed John’s willingness to make personal sacrifices.

The second study aimed to determine if the effects observed were unique to loyalty or applicable to other virtues. The study procedure replicated that of study 1, with the difference that, instead of loyal or disloyal, John was described as either fair, loyal, honest, or no description of John was provided.

The third study described John facing requests for unpaid work, including overtime and tasks unrelated to his job. Participants read about John either accepting or refusing these requests, then evaluated his loyalty, honesty, and fairness.

The fourth study replicated the procedure of study 3, but additionally asked participants to judge the exploitativeness of the tasks and John’s loyalty if he agreed to the unpaid work.

The results revealed that managers were more inclined to assign unpaid extra tasks to John when he was portrayed as loyal, particularly for overtime work. A statistical model suggested that managers view loyal employees as more willing to sacrifice for the company, leading to their exploitation.

The second study confirmed that managers preferred exploiting the “loyal” John over others, with no differentiation when John was described as honest or fair.

The third and fourth studies indicated that managers perceived John as more loyal if he accepted unpaid tasks, without affecting perceptions of his fairness or honesty. The fourth study also found that the more managers viewed the tasks as exploitative, the more loyal they deemed John if he accepted them.

“Society has made some positive strides in formally outlawing egregious kinds of exploitation, but more subtle types of exploitation remain all too common,” , the study authors concluded. “Insofar as exploitative managerial practices persist, certain workers will be targeted for exploitation. Although loyalty is typically touted as a moral virtue worth exemplifying, our research indicates that loyal workers are perceived to be more exploitable than other employees, because of the common assumption that loyal individuals are readily willing to make personal sacrifices for the objects of their loyalty.”

“Given that workers who agree to participate in their own exploitation also acquire stronger reputations for loyalty, the bidirectional causal links between loyalty and exploitation have the potential to create a vicious circle of suffering for certain workers.”

The study sheds light on the relationship between workers’ loyalty and behaviors of managers. However, it should be noted that the study was conducted on short hypothetical one-off scenarios. Results might be more nuanced or not the same at all if real-world relationships were studied.

The paper, “Loyal workers are selectively and ironically targeted for exploitation,” was authored by Matthew L. Stanley, Christopher B. Neck, and Christopher P. Neck.

TweetSendScanShareSendPin1ShareShareShareShareShare

RELATED

Here’s what the data says about who actually benefits from DEI
Business

Here’s what the data says about who actually benefits from DEI

May 31, 2025

What’s the actual impact of diversity, equity, and inclusion? A sociologist unpacks decades of research showing how DEI programs affect businesses, education, and the broader economy—highlighting who benefits, who doesn’t, and what the data really says.

Read moreDetails
Narcissistic CEOs are more likely to fake emotions when they feel lonely, study finds
Business

Narcissistic CEOs are more likely to fake emotions when they feel lonely, study finds

May 29, 2025

When narcissistic CEOs feel lonely, they are more likely to hide their true emotions and perform socially expected ones instead, according to a new study examining how personality and isolation shape emotional behavior at the executive level.

Read moreDetails
Poor sleep can bring out the ‘dark side’ of personality at work, study finds
Business

Poor sleep can bring out the ‘dark side’ of personality at work, study finds

May 29, 2025

New research shows that bad sleep can bring out the worst in people at work. Employees who slept poorly were more likely to display manipulative, narcissistic, and emotionally detached behaviors—traits linked to the so-called “dark triad” of personality.

Read moreDetails
Encountering romantic temptation nudges men and women toward different types of purchases
Business

Encountering romantic temptation nudges men and women toward different types of purchases

May 28, 2025

Experiencing romantic desire for someone outside a relationship can trigger subtle psychological shifts. A new study reveals that these feelings influence what people buy—encouraging men to seek shared experiences and women to opt for practical, lasting possessions.

Read moreDetails
Neuroforecasting: New research shows brain activity can predict crowd preferences
Business

Neuroforecasting: New research shows brain activity can predict crowd preferences

May 21, 2025

A new study reveals that brain activity, particularly in regions linked to emotion, predicts market preferences more accurately than self-reported choices—especially when samples aren’t demographically representative. Neural signals offered consistent forecasts even when behavioral data failed.

Read moreDetails
Political doxing in the hiring process: New study reveals impact on job candidate evaluations
Autism

Why people with autism struggle to get hired

April 23, 2025

New research shows that social behaviors often misunderstood by interviewers can overshadow qualifications, leading to unfair hiring decisions.

Read moreDetails
Money and happiness: Major psychology study reveals surprising differences between income and financial satisfaction
Business

Money and happiness: Major psychology study reveals surprising differences between income and financial satisfaction

April 10, 2025

New research reveals that financial satisfaction is tied to present well-being, but income predicts how people’s happiness shifts over time.

Read moreDetails
A demanding work culture could be quietly undermining efforts to raise birth rates
Business

A demanding work culture could be quietly undermining efforts to raise birth rates

April 1, 2025

Overtime, weekend work, and night shifts are linked to lower fertility intentions in China.

Read moreDetails

SUBSCRIBE

Go Ad-Free! Click here to subscribe to PsyPost and support independent science journalism!

STAY CONNECTED

LATEST

Exposure to heavy metals is associated with higher likelihood of ADHD diagnosis

Eye-tracking study shows people fixate longer on female aggressors than male ones

Romantic breakups follow a two-stage decline that begins years before the split, study finds

Believing “news will find me” is linked to sharing fake news, study finds

A common parasite not only invades the brain — it can also decapitate human sperm

Almost all unmarried pregant women say that the fetus resembles the father, study finds

New neuroscience research reveals brain antioxidant deficit in depression

Scientists uncover kidney-to-brain route for Parkinson’s-related protein spread

         
       
  • Contact us
  • Privacy policy
  • Terms and Conditions
[Do not sell my information]

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist

Subscribe
  • My Account
  • Cognitive Science Research
  • Mental Health Research
  • Social Psychology Research
  • Drug Research
  • Relationship Research
  • About PsyPost
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy