Subscribe
The latest psychology and neuroscience discoveries.
My Account
  • Mental Health
  • Social Psychology
  • Cognitive Science
  • Psychopharmacology
  • Neuroscience
  • About
No Result
View All Result
PsyPost
PsyPost
No Result
View All Result
Home Exclusive Cognitive Science

Metacognitive abilities may be more influenced by environment than genetics

by Eric W. Dolan
May 3, 2024
in Cognitive Science
(Photo credit: Adobe Stock)

(Photo credit: Adobe Stock)

Share on TwitterShare on Facebook
Stay informed on the latest psychology and neuroscience research—follow PsyPost on LinkedIn for daily updates and insights.

In a recent study from Beijing Normal University, researchers have demonstrated that certain cognitive abilities, particularly those related to metacognition and mentalizing, are significantly influenced by environmental factors, potentially more so than by genetics. The study, published in Cell Reports, utilized a twin-based experimental model to explore how both genetic and environmental factors contribute to cognitive processing, revealing surprising insights into how we think and understand our own and others’ mental states.

Research has shown that general intelligence, often measured as Intelligence Quotient (IQ), has a significant heritable component, suggesting that genetics plays a substantial role in cognitive capabilities. However, these findings predominantly apply to basic cognitive functions like memory, perception, and attention, which collectively underpin general intelligence.

In contrast, less is known about more nuanced cognitive functions such as metacognition and mentalizing. Metacognition refers to the awareness and management of one’s own cognitive processes, such as learning and problem-solving, while mentalizing involves understanding and interpreting the mental states of oneself and others, crucial for effective social interaction.

These abilities are fundamental to personal and academic success, making them critical areas of study. However, the extent to which these abilities are influenced by genetic versus environmental factors had not been thoroughly explored.

“Past research has suggested that general intelligence—often referred to as intelligence quotient or IQ—has a heritability ranging from 50% to 80%,” said senior and corresponding author Xiaohong Wan of Beijing Normal University in China. “Our study may be the first to demonstrate that a different kind of cognitive ability, known as metacognition and mentalizing, might be much more influenced by environment.”

The study involved 251 healthy right-handed participants, including 65 pairs of monozygotic twins (who share nearly 100% of their genes) and 55 pairs of dizygotic twins (who share about 50% of their genetic variation), all recruited from the BeTwiSt twin database at the Institute of Psychology, Chinese Academy of Sciences. The researchers assessed the participants’ socioeconomic backgrounds, including education levels and monthly income, to control for these variables in their analysis.

By examining the similarities and differences in traits and behaviors between monozygotic and dizygotic twins, researchers can effectively dissect the contributions of inherited (genetic) factors and environmental factors. If identical twins show more similarity in a trait compared to fraternal twins, it suggests a genetic influence. If both types of twins show similar levels of similarity, it indicates a stronger role for environmental factors.

To assess cognitive functions, each participant underwent two distinct tasks: one for metacognition and another for mentalizing. The metacognition task involved participants observing a visual display of moving dots (random-dot-kinematogram) and determining the overall direction of motion. Participants then rated their confidence in their decision, without receiving feedback on their accuracy. This task evaluated their ability to assess and report their own cognitive processes.

The mentalizing task required participants to estimate the confidence that another twin, either their sibling or another participant, had in their decision on a similar task. This was challenging as participants did not have direct information about the other’s choices or confidence levels; they could only rely on observing the response time.

Contrary to the traditionally high heritability observed in general cognitive abilities like intelligence, the researchers found that metacognition and mentalizing are more strongly influenced by environmental factors than by genetic ones.

Specifically, the researchers observed that for tasks involving metacognitive processes, the similarity in performance between twins could be attributed more to their common upbringing and shared experiences than to their genetic makeup. Similarly, in tasks that required participants to assess the confidence levels of others without direct communication (mentalizing tasks), the results suggested that environmental factors were again predominant over genetic factors.

“Our findings were outside our expectations,” Wan said. “Decades of extensive research utilizing the classical twin paradigm have consistently demonstrated the heritability of nearly all cognitive abilities so far investigated. Our findings emphasize that these shared family environmental factors, such as parental nurturing and the transmission of cultural values, likely play a significant role in shaping the mental state representations in metacognition and mentalizing.”

Despite the robust design and significant findings of the study, the researchers acknowledge several limitations. The tasks used to measure metacognition and mentalizing are complex and may not cover all aspects of these cognitive abilities across different contexts. Furthermore, the effect sizes and statistical powers were modest, suggesting that larger studies might be needed to confirm these findings.

Future research is encouraged to explore these cognitive functions using different tasks and larger, more diverse samples. Additionally, integrating genetic data through genome-wide association studies could further elucidate the genetic underpinnings of these cognitive abilities.

The study, “Distinct genetic and environmental origins of hierarchical cognitive abilities in adult humans,” was authored by Shaohan Jiang, Fanru Sun, Peijun Yuan, Yi Jiang, and Xiaohong Wan.

TweetSendScanShareSendPin3ShareShareShareShareShare

RELATED

Autism severity rooted in embryonic brain growth, study suggests
Cognitive Science

Common pollutant in drinking water linked to brain damage and cognitive impairment

July 17, 2025

New research in mice reveals that prolonged exposure to "forever chemicals," or PFAS, can disrupt brain function and impair memory, even at low concentrations. The findings add to growing evidence that these common chemicals may pose significant risks to brain health.

Read moreDetails
Scientists find genetic basis for how much people enjoy music
Cognitive Science

Is humor inherited? Twin study suggests the ability to be funny may not run in the family

July 10, 2025

A first-of-its-kind study set out to discover whether being funny is something you inherit. By testing twins on their joke-making skills, researchers found that your sense of humor might have less to do with DNA than you'd think.

Read moreDetails
Even in healthy adults, high blood sugar levels are linked to impaired brain function
Memory

Neuroscientists decode how people juggle multiple items in working memory

July 8, 2025

New neuroscience research shows how the brain decides which memories deserve more attention. By tracking brain activity, scientists found that the frontal cortex helps direct limited memory resources, allowing people to remember high-priority information more precisely than less relevant details.

Read moreDetails
New study uncovers a surprising effect of cold-water immersion
Cognitive Science

New study uncovers a surprising effect of cold-water immersion

July 8, 2025

Cold-water immersion increases energy expenditure—but it may also drive people to eat more afterward. A study in Physiology & Behavior found participants consumed significantly more food following cold exposure, possibly due to internal cooling effects that continue after leaving the water.

Read moreDetails
Positive attitudes toward AI linked to problematic social media use
Cognitive Science

People with higher cognitive ability have weaker moral foundations, new study finds

July 7, 2025

A large study has found that individuals with greater cognitive ability are less likely to endorse moral values such as compassion, fairness, loyalty, and purity. The results point to a consistent negative relationship between intelligence and moral intuitions.

Read moreDetails
These common sounds can impair your learning, according to new psychology research
Cognitive Science

These common sounds can impair your learning, according to new psychology research

July 4, 2025

Your brain’s ancient defense system might be sabotaging your test scores. New research suggests our "behavioral immune system," which makes us subconsciously alert to signs of illness, can be triggered by coughs and sniffles.

Read moreDetails
From fireflies to brain cells: Unraveling the complex web of synchrony in networks
Addiction

Understanding “neuronal ensembles” could revolutionize addiction treatment

July 3, 2025

The same brain system that rewards you for a delicious meal is hijacked by drugs like fentanyl. A behavioral neuroscientist explains how understanding the specific memories behind these rewards is the key to treating addiction without harming our essential survival instincts.

Read moreDetails
Scientists just uncovered a surprising illusion in how we remember time
Memory

Scientists just uncovered a surprising illusion in how we remember time

July 3, 2025

Our perception of time is more fragile than we think. Scientists have uncovered a powerful illusion where repeated exposure to information makes us misremember it as happening much further in the past, significantly distorting our mental timelines.

Read moreDetails

SUBSCRIBE

Go Ad-Free! Click here to subscribe to PsyPost and support independent science journalism!

STAY CONNECTED

LATEST

Dopamine’s stronghold is the striatum, not the cortex, brain imaging study suggests

Brain injuries linked to criminal behavior highlight importance of white matter tract damage

Early exposure to violence linked to later firearm use

What friendships can tell us about life satisfaction among singles

Parent’s anxiety sensitivity linked to teen’s brain patterns during emotional challenges

Key Alzheimer’s protein found at astonishingly high levels in healthy newborns

People’s ideal leader isn’t hyper-masculine — new study shows preference for androgynous traits

Chronic pain rewires how the brain processes punishment, new research suggests

         
       
  • Contact us
  • Privacy policy
  • Terms and Conditions
[Do not sell my information]

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist

Subscribe
  • My Account
  • Cognitive Science Research
  • Mental Health Research
  • Social Psychology Research
  • Drug Research
  • Relationship Research
  • About PsyPost
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy