A study of 7- to 9-year-olds found that children who regularly practiced a musical instrument tended to score higher on tests of cognitive ability and academic achievement than children without musical training. Brain scans also hinted at a difference in a right-hemisphere white matter pathway connecting auditory and motor regions, though this finding was not statistically robust. The paper was published in Developmental Cognitive Neuroscience.
Childhood is an important period of brain development, during which environmental experiences can influence the structure and functioning of the brain. Participating in extracurricular activities, such as learning to play a musical instrument, may contribute to children’s cognitive development.
Research has found that musical training can improve music-related abilities, such as recognizing rhythms and melodies, but its benefits may also extend to non-musical skills. Studies have reported improvements in executive functioning, reading comprehension, language abilities, and academic performance among children who received musical training. Some studies have also found that these improvements are accompanied by changes in brain activity and connectivity.
Researchers have used brain imaging techniques to investigate how musical training relates to the structure of white matter, which consists of nerve fibers connecting different brain regions. Of particular interest is the arcuate fasciculus, a bundle of nerve fibers connecting brain regions involved in language, auditory processing, and related functions. Previous research has linked the structure of this pathway to language learning, speech perception, and musical abilities, but its relationship with musical training and cognitive development in children remains insufficiently understood.
Don’t miss the next big psychology finding
Every morning, PsyPost sends a short briefing on the most interesting new peer-reviewed research in psychology and neuroscience.
Study author Kelsie L. Lopez of Northeastern University and colleagues wanted to evaluate the relationship between musical training, cognitive ability, and the microstructure of white matter within the arcuate fasciculus. To do this, they analyzed existing data from the FITKids2 study, a randomized controlled trial of a physical activity program for 7- to 9-year-olds in East Central Illinois. The researchers used only data collected before the physical activity program began, and the study did not involve a music intervention.
The researchers hypothesized that children who play an instrument would have higher cognitive scores and perform better academically than their musically untrained peers. They also expected musically trained children to show differences in the white matter of the arcuate fasciculus.
Children were classified as musically trained if a caregiver reported that they played an instrument and practiced for more than 30 minutes a week. Of 175 children with complete data, 38 had musical training and 137 did not, and about 58% of each group were girls. The musically trained children most often played the piano (29), followed by string instruments such as the violin, viola, or cello (eight) and plucked string instruments such as the guitar or ukulele (four).
Children completed a battery of cognitive tests, including the Woodcock-Johnson Psycho-Educational Battery, Third Edition, which measures general intelligence and various specific cognitive abilities, and the Operation Span task, which measures working memory. They also completed the Kaufman Test of Educational Achievement, Second Edition, which assesses mathematics, reading, spelling, writing, and listening comprehension. Of the 175 children, 96 had usable brain imaging data.
Because the two groups differed greatly in size, the researchers matched each musically trained child with a child without musical training of similar age, sex, and socioeconomic status. The analyses of cognition and academic achievement compared these two matched groups of 38 children each, while the brain imaging comparisons used two matched groups of 25 children each.
Results showed that children with musical training scored higher than their peers on several cognitive measures, including general intelligence, brief intellectual ability, thinking ability, spatial relations, verbal comprehension, visual-auditory learning, and working memory. The groups did not differ on several other measures, such as cognitive efficiency and planning. Children with musical training also scored higher on all composite measures of academic achievement, including reading, math, and written language, and on most individual subtests.
Analysis of brain imaging data found a possible difference in the right arcuate fasciculus, along the pathway connecting the precentral gyrus, a motor region, and the posterior superior temporal gyrus, an auditory region. Children with musical training had a higher mode of anisotropy in this pathway, a measure reflecting whether nerve fibers tend to run in a single direction rather than crossing one another. However, this difference was no longer statistically significant after the researchers corrected for multiple comparisons, and no differences emerged in the left hemisphere or on other measures of white matter structure.
“When comparing children who regularly practice an instrument to children without musical training, children with musical training outperformed children without musical training on assessments of cognition and academic achievement and demonstrated higher mode in the right PCG-STGp tract within the arcuate fasciculus [the pathway connecting the precentral gyrus and posterior superior temporal gyrus]. Taken together, results of the present study provide evidence for the value of playing an instrument in the childhood window of rapid cognitive and neural development,” the study authors concluded.
The study contributes to the scientific understanding of potential correlates of musical training in children. However, it should be noted that the design of the study does not allow any causal inferences to be derived from the results. The authors note that children who play instruments may also benefit from broader family enrichment and greater involvement in extracurricular activities, which could help explain their higher scores.
Musical training was based on caregiver reports, and the researchers did not measure how intensively children practiced or how proficient they were. The matching approach also meant that most children without musical training were excluded from the analyses, and the brain imaging comparisons involved only 50 children scanned at relatively low resolution.
The paper, “Musical training is associated with cognitive outcomes and white matter microstructure in middle childhood,” was authored by Kelsie L. Lopez, Yaen Chen, Roger Burtonpatel, Lauren Raine, Arthur F. Kramer, Charles H. Hillman, and Psyche Loui.