Subscribe
The latest psychology and neuroscience discoveries.
My Account
  • Mental Health
  • Social Psychology
  • Cognitive Science
  • Psychopharmacology
  • Neuroscience
  • About
No Result
View All Result
PsyPost
PsyPost
No Result
View All Result
Home Exclusive Social Psychology

Psychologists have identified a pervasive illusion that has existed for at least 70 years

by Eric W. Dolan
June 27, 2023
in Social Psychology
Share on TwitterShare on Facebook
Stay informed on the latest psychology and neuroscience research—follow PsyPost on LinkedIn for daily updates and insights.

A series of studies has found that people tend to believe morality has declined over time, regardless of the decade or country they were in, and that they tend to think the decline started around the time they were born. The findings, published in Nature, suggest there is a pervasive illusion of moral decline that is the result, at least in part, of two common psychological biases.

“My whole life, I’ve heard people claim that humans are less good to each other than they used to be. ‘When I was a kid, you could leave your door unlocked,’ that sort of thing,” explained study author Adam Mastroianni, an experimental psychologist and the author of the science blog Experimental History.

“If people are right about that, it’s the story of the century! Every scientist should stop what they’re doing and figure out how to restore morality. But if people are wrong, we have another interesting question on our hands: why do people think this has happened when it actually hasn’t?”

To gather initial data regarding the perception of moral decline, the researchers performed keyword-term searches in the Roper Center for Public Opinion iPoll Database and manually searched databases such as the General Social Survey, Pew Research Center, Gallup, the American National Election Studies, the World Values Survey, the European Social Survey, and the European Values Survey. The goal was to locate survey items that asked participants about their perceptions of changes in morality over time.

Across the 177 survey items identified, 84.18% of participants in the United States reported that morality had declined. Importantly, this perception remained consistent over the 70-year span from 1949 to 2019, indicating that U.S. residents have been reporting moral decline at the same rate throughout this period. This finding suggests that the belief in moral decline is not a recent phenomenon but has been a long-standing perception.

Interestingly, participants were more likely to perceive moral decline when asked about longer periods of time (e.g., the last few decades) compared to shorter periods (e.g., the last year).

The perception of moral decline was not unique to U.S. residents. An analysis of survey items from 59 nations, involving a total of 354,120 participants, showed that on 86.21% of the items, the majority of participants also reported that morality had declined. This finding indicates that people across the world share a belief in the decline of morality.

In a series of three additional studies, the researchers asked U.S. participants to rate how “kind, honest, nice, and good” people were in the present day compared to the past. The participants — 1,230 in total — were recruited through Prolific and Amazon Mechanical Turk. All three studies found a similar pattern of results: participants perceived a moral decline in people over time. For example, participants rated people as less kind, honest, nice, and good in 2020 compared to 2010 and 2000.

Older participants perceived more decline than younger participants. However, when considering the annual rate of moral decline, it was found that older participants did not perceive a higher rate compared to younger participants. The researchers found that the perception of greater moral decline among older participants was primarily due to considering longer periods of time.

“Older and younger people seem to perceive about the same amount of decline,” Mastroianni said.

In another study of 319 U.S. residents, the researchers found evidence that people attributed the moral decline to both the decreasing morality of individuals over time and the decreasing morality of successive generations.

The researchers then analyzed data from surveys conducted over a 55-year period that had asked participants to report on various aspects of current morality. The results indicated that people’s assessments of the current morality of their contemporaries did not change significantly over time. The year in which the survey was conducted explained less than 1% of the variance in responses, suggesting that any changes in reported morality were negligible at best. In other words, there was no evidence that morality was actually in decline.

Mastroianni also noted that a study published last year, which analyzed 511 studies conducted over the course of 61 years, found evidence that cooperative behavior had actually increased over time.

“There’s a study that we didn’t have space for in the main text, but that answers the question in a different way. Social scientists have, for decades, brought people into the lab and asked them to play various ‘economic games’ –– basically, they can choose to be greedy and make more money, or they can choose to be generous and make less money,” Mastroianni explained.

“Previous researchers have found that cooperation rates in these games actually increased about 10 percentage points from 1956 to 2017. When we asked participants to estimate that change and paid them a bonus for getting it right, they thought that cooperation had fallen by about 10 percentage points.”

The authors proposed a mechanism called the “biased exposure and memory” (BEAM) to explain why people perceived moral decline despite evidence to the contrary. This mechanism suggests that biased exposure to negative information about current morality and biased memory for positive information about past morality can create an illusion of moral decline. The tendency to focus on negative information and the selective recall of positive events from the past work together to shape people’s perception of moral change.

“Most people in the world believe that humans are less good to one another than they used to be,” Mastroianni said. But “they’re almost certainly wrong about that. Two psychological phenomena can combine to produce that illusion.”

To test this mechanism, the researchers conducted two more studies, which included 670 U.S. residents in total. They found that when participants were asked to rate the moral change among people in their personal worlds rather than people in general, they tended to report moral improvement over time, suggesting a reversal of the illusion of moral decline.

When participants were asked to rate the morality of people in general in the years before they were born, they tended to perceived moral decline in the years after their birth but not before, supporting the idea that biased memory contributes to the illusion of moral decline.

But like all research, the studies have limitations. Some of the data used were not specifically collected for studying moral decline, and some questions were not clear or precise enough. Additionally, the studies focused on the United States, which limits generalizability. The studies also couldn’t determine the exact cause of the illusion of moral decline.

“We’re limited by the archival data we have available, which only goes back to 1949 at the earliest,” Mastroianni said.

The study, “The illusion of moral decline“, was authored by Adam M. Mastroianni and Daniel T. Gilbert.

TweetSendScanShareSendPin1ShareShareShareShareShare

RELATED

Gynandromorph research offers insight into the complexities of male sexual attraction
Sexism

Eye-tracking study shows people fixate longer on female aggressors than male ones

June 23, 2025

People pay more visual attention to female aggressors than male ones, but do not consistently judge their actions as more intentional or blameworthy, suggesting that female aggression is seen as unexpected rather than more morally significant.

Read moreDetails
Breakups can trigger trauma in emerging adults
Relationships and Sexual Health

Romantic breakups follow a two-stage decline that begins years before the split, study finds

June 23, 2025

A new study shows that romantic relationships often begin to unravel one to two years before they officially end. Researchers found a two-phase pattern of decline in satisfaction that could help identify when relationships are heading for a breakup.

Read moreDetails
It’s not digital illiteracy: Here’s why older adults are drawn to dubious news
Social Media

Believing “news will find me” is linked to sharing fake news, study finds

June 22, 2025

People who rely on social media to “stumble upon” news are more prone to spreading misinformation, according to a new longitudinal study.

Read moreDetails
Political ambivalence has a surprising relationship with support for violence
Authoritarianism

New study sheds light on the psychological roots of collective violence

June 21, 2025

A new study from Lebanon finds that people with authoritarian beliefs tend to oppose violence against political leaders, while those high in social dominance orientation are more likely to support violence against rival group members.

Read moreDetails
Scientists observe reduced emotional distress in children living near greenery
Racism and Discrimination

Adults’ beliefs about children and race shift when a child’s race is specified, study finds

June 21, 2025

Specifying a child’s race alters how adults perceive their awareness of race and racism, according to new research. Black children are viewed as less “color-evasive” and more racially aware at earlier ages than White children or generic “children.”

Read moreDetails
Study helps untangle the complicated relationship between psychopathy and emotional awareness
Psychopathy

Psychopathic individuals recognize unfairness but are less likely to punish it

June 21, 2025

A new study shows that individuals with higher psychopathic traits are less likely to punish unfair behavior, especially when it costs them personally. The research suggests self-interest, not a lack of moral understanding, drives their reluctance to enforce social norms.

Read moreDetails
The neuroscience of why we cry happy tears
Social Psychology

The neuroscience of why we cry happy tears

June 20, 2025

Why do people cry happy tears? Neuroscience suggests these emotional outbursts occur when the brain becomes overwhelmed by joy, nostalgia, or relief. Far from being irrational, crying during joyful moments helps restore balance and deepen human connection.

Read moreDetails
Epistemic mistrust and dogmatism predict preference for authoritarian-looking leaders
Authoritarianism

Epistemic mistrust and dogmatism predict preference for authoritarian-looking leaders

June 20, 2025

A new study suggests that the way people learn to trust others early in life can shape their political ideology and preference for strong, dominant leaders—though not directly, but through dogmatic thinking and broader political attitudes.

Read moreDetails

SUBSCRIBE

Go Ad-Free! Click here to subscribe to PsyPost and support independent science journalism!

STAY CONNECTED

LATEST

Exposure to heavy metals is associated with higher likelihood of ADHD diagnosis

Eye-tracking study shows people fixate longer on female aggressors than male ones

Romantic breakups follow a two-stage decline that begins years before the split, study finds

Believing “news will find me” is linked to sharing fake news, study finds

A common parasite not only invades the brain — it can also decapitate human sperm

Almost all unmarried pregant women say that the fetus resembles the father, study finds

New neuroscience research reveals brain antioxidant deficit in depression

Scientists uncover kidney-to-brain route for Parkinson’s-related protein spread

         
       
  • Contact us
  • Privacy policy
  • Terms and Conditions
[Do not sell my information]

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist

Subscribe
  • My Account
  • Cognitive Science Research
  • Mental Health Research
  • Social Psychology Research
  • Drug Research
  • Relationship Research
  • About PsyPost
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy