PsyPost
  • Mental Health
  • Social Psychology
  • Cognitive Science
  • Neuroscience
  • About
No Result
View All Result
Join
My Account
PsyPost
No Result
View All Result
Home Exclusive Social Psychology

Three problems with using the trolley dilemma in moral philosophy

by Mane Kara-Yakoubian
March 1, 2024
Reading Time: 2 mins read
(Photo credit: Adobe Stock)

(Photo credit: Adobe Stock)

Add as a preferred source on GoogleFollow on Google News

In a recent paper published in the Journal of Ethics and Social Philosophy, Guy Crian critiques the “trolley method” of moral philosophy for its unrealistic simplification of moral decision-making, lack of consideration for the complexity and diversity of real-life ethical situations, and potential to mislead about the nature of moral agency and ethical reasoning.

First, the trolley method emphasizes dramatic scenarios that are rare or extreme compared to the everyday ethical decisions that people face. This focus on high-stakes dilemmas, such as choosing between the lives of different individuals, neglects the more common and less dramatic aspects of moral life, such as showing kindness, making personal sacrifices, or engaging in civic duties. By highlighting such exceptional cases, the method distorts the perception of ethics as primarily concerned with life-and-death decisions, overlooking the mundane but pervasive ethical considerations that shape our daily lives and relationships.

Second, the method tends to present moral agents as generic or anonymized figures, ostensibly to make the scenarios universally applicable. However, this approach overlooks the fact that respondents often unconsciously fill in missing details based on their own biases or assumptions, such as imagining the moral agent as a young, able-bodied male. This implicit shaping of the moral agent’s identity excludes a wide range of potential agents from consideration, such as those who are elderly, disabled, or from diverse cultural backgrounds, thereby narrowing the scope of ethical inquiry to a limited set of perspectives.

Third, the critique points out that the trolley method models ethical decision-making as a clear-cut choice between distinct options. Real-life ethical decision-making is often automatic and influenced by factors beyond immediate conscious deliberation. Factors such as cultural background, personal history, psychological state, and even physical environment can subtly influence decisions in ways individuals may not be fully aware of. The critique emphasizes the need for ethical theories to account for these influences, recognizing that ethical behavior is often the result of deeply ingrained habits, societal cues, and situational pressures rather than isolated, deliberate choices.

Free daily newsletter

Don’t miss the next big psychology finding

Every morning, PsyPost sends a short briefing on the most interesting new peer-reviewed research in psychology and neuroscience.

✓ Free ✓ One email a day ✓ Unsubscribe anytime

Crain acknowledges the educational and psychological value of trolley problems but criticizes their dominance in moral philosophy for failing to address the full range of ethical experiences and decisions. The critique calls for a broader, more nuanced approach to ethics that considers the complexity of human life, the diversity of moral agents, and the everyday nature of most ethical decision-making.

The critique, “Three Shortcomings of the Trolley Method of Moral Philosophy”, was authored by Guy Crain.

TweetSendScanShareSendPin2ShareShareShareShareShare

Follow PsyPost

The latest research, however you prefer to read it.

Daily newsletter

One email a day. The newest research, nothing else.

Google News

Get PsyPost stories in your Google News feed.

Add PsyPost to Google News
RSS feed

Use your favorite reader.

Copy RSS URL
Social media
Support independent science journalism

Ad-free reading, full archives, and weekly deep dives for members.

Become a member

Trending

  • Regret is rare among transgender youth who began hormone therapy, according to largest study of its kind
  • Bedroom temperature may be a hidden drag on productivity, study suggests
  • Greater male variability may help explain persistent gender gaps in hiring, study suggests
  • The best conversations may follow a hidden mathematical rhythm called pink noise, according to new psychology research
  • Irritable kids are hard to parent, and that strain may show up years later, new study suggests

Science of Money

  • The hidden social cost of cashierless stores
  • Can brain scans help retailers predict grocery sales?
  • Why combining four small coupons feels better than getting one big discount
  • Does menopause alter how women handle financial risk?
  • What lottery winners reveal about how different income groups spend, save, and work

Recent

  • Unwavering cooperators make group efforts easier to start but harder to sustain
  • Popular cannabis supplement shows inconsistent anti-inflammatory effects in brain cells
  • People who feel humiliated tend to be less happy, and rumination may partly explain why
  • New case study offers causal evidence linking the right amygdala to PTSD
  • People tend to underestimate how much they get in the way of their partner’s goals
  • Scientists created a Doctor Octopus-inspired brain interface for controlling robotic arms
  • Young women widely believe that each person has a single ideal romantic partner destined for them, Turkish study finds
  • Flashy courtship traits tend to evolve faster than combat weapons, study finds
  • Scientists built an AI called “Concept2Brain” that simulates human brain waves from pictures and text
  • Screens, inherited childhood scripts, and therapy skepticism lead this week’s psychology podcasts

PsyPost is a psychology and neuroscience news website dedicated to reporting the latest research on human behavior, cognition, and society. (READ MORE...)

  • Mental Health
  • Neuroimaging
  • Personality Psychology
  • Social Psychology
  • Artificial Intelligence
  • Cognitive Science
  • Psychopharmacology
  • Contact us
  • Disclaimer
  • Privacy policy
  • Terms and conditions
  • FAQ

(c) PsyPost Media Inc

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist

Subscribe
  • My Account
  • Cognitive Science Research
  • Mental Health Research
  • Social Psychology Research
  • Drug Research
  • Relationship Research
  • About PsyPost
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy

(c) PsyPost Media Inc