A small neuroimaging study found that a 30-minute moderate-intensity walk changed patterns of brain activity during a task requiring cognitive flexibility, and that some of these changes differed by age. After walking, activation in the right dorsolateral prefrontal cortex remained stable in older adults but declined in young adults, while activation in several parietal regions held steady after walking but declined after sitting in both age groups. Task performance, however, did not change. The paper was published in the Journal of Magnetic Resonance Imaging.
Aerobic exercise is physical activity, such as brisk walking, running, swimming, or cycling, that increases heart rate and breathing. It is called aerobic because, during such activities, muscle cells produce most of their energy through aerobic cellular respiration, a process that uses oxygen to extract energy from fats and carbohydrates. Studies indicate that a single session of aerobic exercise may temporarily improve cognitive performance. However, scientists do not yet fully understand how this happens.
One cognitive ability potentially affected by aerobic exercise that researchers have been particularly interested in is executive function. Executive function is a set of mental processes that allow people to plan, control their behavior, and pursue goals. An important component of executive function is cognitive flexibility, which is the ability to switch between tasks and adapt to changing circumstances. This ability relies on several interconnected brain regions, particularly those in the frontal and parietal lobes.
Studies using functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI), a technique that measures changes in blood oxygenation associated with brain activity, suggest that a single session of moderate-intensity exercise may alter activity in brain regions involved in executive functions. However, researchers still do not fully understand how these changes depend on factors such as age and sex, or how to distinguish the effects of exercise from improvements caused by repeatedly performing the same cognitive tasks.
Don’t miss the next big psychology finding
Every morning, PsyPost sends a short briefing on the most interesting new peer-reviewed research in psychology and neuroscience.
Study author Ryota Asahara and colleagues wanted to examine how a single session of aerobic exercise affects brain activity during a cognitive flexibility task in healthy young and older adults. They measured brain activity using the blood-oxygen-level-dependent (BOLD) signal, which reflects changes in blood oxygenation linked to neural activity. They hypothesized that a 30-minute walk would increase brain activation in older adults and improve their performance. They also expected that repeating the same task would reduce brain activation while improving performance, and that these effects would differ by age.
Study participants were 17 healthy young adults, with an average age of 25, and 19 older adults, with an average age of 62. Eight of the young adults and 10 of the older adults were women. Participants were screened to exclude cognitive impairment, psychiatric or neurological disorders, high blood pressure, and diabetes.
Each participant completed two experimental sessions at least two days apart. In one session, they walked on a treadmill at moderate intensity for 30 minutes, and in the other, they sat quietly for the same amount of time. The order of the two conditions was randomized.
During each session, participants completed three fMRI scans: one before walking or sitting, one about 15 minutes afterward, and one about 45 minutes afterward. During the scans, participants performed three types of tasks. In two nonswitch tasks, they judged a stimulus based only on its shape or only on its color. In the switch task, a cue indicated whether to judge shape or color, so participants had to alternate between the two rules, which tested their cognitive flexibility.
Compared with young adults, older adults showed greater brain activation during task switching in several regions, including the superior frontal gyri, middle temporal gyri, right angular gyrus, and left precuneus, even though their overall task performance was slightly lower. No regions showed greater activation in young adults than in older adults. The authors suggest that older adults may recruit additional brain regions to maintain their performance.
Across both groups, repeating the task reduced activation related to task switching in the left middle occipital gyrus, left middle frontal gyrus, and right cerebellum. The extra time needed to switch between tasks decreased with repetition only in older adults. Reductions in brain activation with repetition were linked to faster responses, particularly in older adults, which the authors interpret as a sign of more efficient processing.
After walking, activation in the right dorsolateral prefrontal cortex remained stable in older participants but declined in young participants. Regardless of age, activation in the right postcentral gyrus and both superior parietal lobules, regions that support shifting attention, held steady after walking but declined after sitting. The authors suggest that exercise may counteract the declines in brain activation that occur when a task is repeated.
However, walking did not improve task performance compared with sitting in either age group, and no exercise effects were found in other brain regions the researchers had selected in advance. The authors note that the strong effects of task repetition may have masked modest benefits of exercise.
“Thirty-minute, moderate-intensity walking maintained regional BOLD activation involved in task switching in healthy young and older adults compared with sitting. This suggests that acute aerobic exercise may counteract repetition-related reductions in brain activation, particularly within the frontal and parietal regions supporting executive function. Although behavioral performance did not significantly improve following exercise, the repetition-related effects may have obscured modest exercise effects. These findings suggest that acute aerobic exercise may influence the brain’s neural processes before detectable behavioral changes, particularly in older adults,” the study authors concluded.
The study contributes to the scientific understanding of changes in brain activity after exercise. However, it should be noted that the study was conducted on a small group of participants, and findings from larger studies may differ. In addition, the BOLD signal reflects blood flow as well as neural activity, and because exercise increases blood flow, the observed changes may partly reflect vascular rather than neural effects.
The study also used only one cognitive task, and the 16-minute task sessions may have produced strong learning effects. Exercise intensity was based on age-predicted maximum heart rate rather than individual fitness testing, and factors such as regular physical activity and sleep were not measured.
The paper, “Effects of Acute Aerobic Exercise and Task Repetition on the Neural Correlates of Executive Function in Young and Older Adults: A Crossover fMRI Study,” was authored by Ryota Asahara, Marina Fukuie, Daisuke Hoshi, Junyeon Won, Rong Zhang, Jun Sugawara, and Takashi Tarumi.