An analysis of UK Biobank data found that people with a larger cortical surface area, the total area of the brain’s folded outer layer, tended to score slightly higher on a short test of verbal and numerical reasoning. The associations were strongest for the dorsolateral prefrontal and superior temporal regions, and genetic analyses suggested the relationship between surface area and cognitive ability may run in both directions. The paper was published in Human Brain Mapping.
Intelligence, also known as general cognitive ability or the g-factor, is strongly influenced by genetics, with genetic factors explaining up to 80% of individual differences in intelligence. However, scientists still do not fully understand how differences in brain structure relate to differences in intelligence.
Research using magnetic resonance imaging has shown that people with larger brains tend to have higher intelligence. However, the strength of this association is relatively modest. More recently, researchers have shifted their attention from overall brain volume to two characteristics of the cerebral cortex: its surface area and thickness. The cerebral cortex is the outer layer of the brain, involved in complex cognitive processes such as reasoning, memory, and decision-making.
Studies suggest that the relationship between brain volume and intelligence is largely explained by genetic factors and is primarily associated with greater cortical surface area rather than cortical thickness. Some studies have also found that higher intelligence is associated with a thinner cortex in certain brain regions, although findings regarding the contributions of individual regions have been inconsistent.
Don’t miss the next big psychology finding
Every morning, PsyPost sends a short briefing on the most interesting new peer-reviewed research in psychology and neuroscience.
Study author Chun-Ju Chou and colleagues set out to identify features of the cerebral cortex associated with general cognitive ability. Rather than dividing the cortex using a traditional anatomical map, they used a brain atlas based on genetics, which groups together areas of the cortex that share genetic influences. They expected that this approach would reveal multiple regions linked to cognitive ability, with surface area and thickness showing different patterns.
The researchers analyzed data from the UK Biobank, a large-scale biomedical research database containing genetic, health, lifestyle, and brain imaging data from approximately 500,000 participants in the United Kingdom.
The researchers started with data from 34,842 participants of European ancestry who had brain imaging data available. After removing closely related individuals and those without cognitive test scores, the analyses included 11,289 participants. Their ages ranged from 45 to 80 years, with an average of 64, and slightly more than half were women.
The researchers used participants’ genetic data and their scores on 13 verbal and numerical reasoning questions, which participants had two minutes to answer. Verbal and numerical reasoning is the ability to understand, analyze, and solve problems involving language, numbers, and logical relationships. Although the UK Biobank labels this test a measure of fluid intelligence, the authors note that it likely captures both fluid and crystallized abilities, and they treated scores on it as a proxy for general cognitive ability.
Results showed that participants with a larger total cortical surface area tended to perform better on the reasoning questions, although surface area explained only about 2.4% of the differences in scores. All regions showed this positive association, with the strongest in the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex, which is involved in working memory and executive function, followed by the superior temporal and orbitofrontal areas. After accounting for total surface area, the dorsolateral prefrontal and superior temporal areas remained positively associated with test performance.
In contrast, associations between cortical thickness and test performance were modest. After accounting for overall thickness, people with a thinner cortex in some frontal and temporal regions tended to score higher.
The researchers also used Mendelian randomization, a method that uses genetic variants as natural experiments to probe whether one trait may influence another. These analyses suggested that a larger total cortical surface area may contribute to higher cognitive ability, and that higher cognitive ability may in turn contribute to a larger surface area. Higher cognitive ability also appeared to influence the thickness of the perisylvian region, an area involved in language processing. At the regional level, the genetic analyses pointed to possible effects of dorsolateral prefrontal and temporal surface area on cognitive ability, but these regional effects did not remain statistically significant after correction for multiple comparisons.
“These findings support a polyregional SA [surface area of multiple regions] architecture underlying GCA [general cognitive ability], with prominent contributions from prefrontal and temporal association cortices. Our results refine global brain–GCA models [models about the relationship between brain characteristics and general cognitive ability] and highlight the value of genetically informed parcellation for identifying regional cortical contributions,” the study authors concluded.
The study contributes to the scientific understanding of the neural correlates of cognitive abilities. However, it should be noted that general cognitive ability was measured using a short test of verbal and numerical reasoning, which the authors describe as a proxy rather than a comprehensive measure of intelligence. General cognitive ability encompasses a wider range of abilities than those assessed by these questions.
The authors also emphasize that cortical structure explained only a small share of the differences in test scores, so the findings reflect population-level associations and cannot be used to predict an individual’s intelligence. Mendelian randomization relies on assumptions that cannot be fully verified, and the sample included only middle-aged and older adults of European ancestry, so the results may not generalize to other groups.
The paper, “Cerebral Cortical Structural Variation and General Cognitive Ability: Evidence From Mendelian Randomization,” was authored by Chun-Ju Chou, Mark Fiecas, Elisabetta C. del Re, Eero Vuoksimaa, and Chi-Hua Chen.