Young adults who experience symptoms of attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder or who have a history of childhood trauma report higher rates of unsafe driving behaviors. However, a new study reveals that while both factors independently increase the likelihood of dangerous driving, childhood adversity does not amplify the risks associated with the disorder. These findings were published in the journal Psychological Reports.
Motor vehicle crashes are a leading cause of death among young adults in the United States. Safety organizations estimate that tens of thousands of people die in traffic accidents every year. Drivers between the ages of 15 and 29 face a particularly high risk on the road. Identifying the underlying psychological factors that contribute to this heightened risk can help experts design targeted safety interventions and reduce traffic fatalities.
Psychology researchers frequently study attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder, known as ADHD, as a major risk factor for negative driving outcomes. ADHD is a neurodevelopmental condition defined by persistent patterns of inattention, hyperactivity, and impulsivity. Inattention involves difficulty sustaining focus or wandering off task. Hyperactivity and impulsivity involve excessive motor activity or making hasty actions without considering the consequences.
Young adults with ADHD often experience more driving citations, license suspensions, and car crashes than their peers. Yet, not all drivers with ADHD face the exact same level of risk. Many individuals with the condition do not experience crashes; one survey found that 60 percent of drivers with ADHD had not had even a minor crash in the previous year. This variation suggests that other underlying variables might influence how dangerous the roads are for a specific driver.
Don’t miss the next big psychology finding
Every morning, PsyPost sends a short briefing on the most interesting new peer-reviewed research in psychology and neuroscience.
Lead author Adam C. Haag, a psychology researcher at Saint Louis University, alongside colleagues Annie A. Garner, Terri L. Weaver, Phillip D. Ruppert, and Christopher J. Schmank, investigated one potential contributing factor. They focused on adverse childhood experiences, commonly called ACEs. These encompass stressful or traumatic events occurring before age 18. Examples include physical, emotional, or sexual abuse, as well as household dysfunction like parental separation or family substance abuse.
Children with ADHD frequently report higher numbers of adverse childhood experiences than those without the disorder. Research suggests a cyclical relationship between the two. The behavioral symptoms of ADHD can sometimes elicit harsher discipline from parents, which adds to a child’s trauma. At the same time, experiencing childhood adversity can lead to ongoing stress that mimics or worsens the symptoms of ADHD. Both conditions can also impair executive functioning, which are the mental skills that help people inhibit their immediate desires and shift their focus safely.
Because both ADHD and childhood trauma are independently linked to poor driving outcomes in early adulthood, the research team set out to test a specific concept called vulnerability. In this context, vulnerability means that the presence of one risk factor makes the effects of a second risk factor even stronger. The researchers wanted to see if a high number of adverse childhood experiences would amplify the unsafe driving behaviors associated with ADHD.
To test this idea, the researchers surveyed 263 licensed drivers between the ages of 18 and 29. The participants completed a series of questionnaires to evaluate their current mental health and their driving habits. One section asked participants to rate how often they exhibit inattentive and hyperactive symptoms. Another section asked them to recall their exposure to childhood adversity, including household dysfunction and physical abuse.
The survey also measured two distinct types of unsafe driving. The first type was risky driving, which involves aggressive actions, speeding, and ignoring traffic laws. The second type was distracted driving, which specifically involves engaging with a cell phone or social media behind the wheel. The researchers excluded data from participants who failed attention-check questions to ensure the final results reflected honest responses.
In their first analysis, the researchers looked at overall ADHD scores. They found that participants with higher total ADHD scores reported engaging in higher amounts of both risky and distracted driving. Similarly, individuals who reported a higher number of adverse childhood experiences also reported more frequent risky driving. Childhood trauma was not linked to distracted driving.
When looking at the interaction between the two risk factors, the results were not statistically significant. Experiencing more childhood trauma did not multiply the driving risks associated with ADHD. Instead, the results point to a concept called equifinality. This means that ADHD symptoms and childhood adversity act as independent risk factors that each increase a person’s chances of driving unsafely. The authors describe their effects as overlapping rather than multiplicative.
Next, the researchers analyzed the two primary dimensions of ADHD separately. Participants with higher levels of inattention reported higher rates of risky driving, but they did not report more distracted driving. The researchers attributed this to the different types of attention required behind the wheel. Distracted driving, like texting, requires a voluntary shift in attention toward a specific object. General inattention involves an involuntary distractibility, where the brain struggles to ignore random sights and sounds.
Conversely, symptoms of hyperactivity and impulsivity predicted both risky driving and distracted driving. To figure out which ADHD dimension mattered most, the research team ran a supplemental analysis placing both sets of symptoms into a single statistical model. When tested together against the driving data, only hyperactivity and impulsivity reliably predicted risky driving. Inattention lost its predictive power in this combined model.
This specific finding suggests that the restless and impulsive elements of ADHD drive the most danger on the road. Individuals who struggle to control their impulses may find it harder to resist checking a text message or speeding past a slow vehicle. The authors noted that future training interventions for young drivers might see the best results by specifically targeting these hyperactive and impulsive tendencies.
The researchers also proposed a psychological explanation for why childhood trauma predicted aggressive driving but not texting. People who endure adverse childhood experiences often develop higher levels of sensation-seeking behavior later in life. Sensation-seeking involves a desire for novel, thrilling, and intense experiences. Speeding down a highway or weaving through traffic provides a rush of adrenaline that satisfies this urge. Texting or reading social media while driving does not typically provide the same physical thrill, which might explain why childhood trauma did not predict distracted cell phone use.
The study relies entirely on self-reported survey data gathered at a single point in time. This cross-sectional design means the results cannot prove that ADHD symptoms or childhood trauma directly cause risky driving behaviors. Using self-reported questionnaires can also introduce bias. Participants might not remember their childhoods accurately, or they might underreport how often they speed and look at their phones.
Due to a survey administration error, the researchers only included nine of the 11 standard questions used to measure adverse childhood experiences. This omission restricted the maximum number of traumatic events participants could report. If the full questionnaire had been utilized, the baseline rates of trauma might have been higher, and the relationship between childhood trauma and driving outcomes might have looked different.
Moving forward, scientists will need to track drivers over a longer period to see how childhood trauma and mental health conditions lead to specific driving habits. Studies could also examine objective driving records, such as police citations and insurance crash reports, rather than relying solely on driver surveys. Exploring the exact reasons why childhood trauma relates to aggressive driving, such as a trauma-induced tendency to seek out intense sensations, could help experts design better safety programs.
The study, “Adverse Childhood Experiences as a Moderator of Attention Deficit/ Hyperactivity Disorder and Risky and Distracted Driving,” was authored by Adam C. Haag, Annie A. Garner, Terri L. Weaver, Phillip D. Ruppert, and Christopher J. Schmank.