PsyPost
  • Mental Health
  • Social Psychology
  • Cognitive Science
  • Neuroscience
  • About
No Result
View All Result
Join
My Account
PsyPost
No Result
View All Result
Home Exclusive Cognitive Science

Massive field experiment suggests classroom phone bans modestly improve college grades

by Eric W. Dolan
November 22, 2026
Reading Time: 8 mins read
[Adobe Stock]

[Adobe Stock]

Add as a preferred source on GoogleFollow on Google News

Requiring college students to store their smartphones in wooden boxes during lectures tends to produce modest improvements in academic performance, according to a large-scale field experiment published in Science. The gains were concentrated among lower-performing students and first-year undergraduates, and students who experienced the classroom rule generally became more supportive of phone restrictions by the end of the semester.

Classroom smartphone bans are policies that require students to hand over or store away their mobile devices during instructional time rather than keeping them at their desks. Education systems around the world have increasingly adopted these rules in primary and secondary schools to reduce distraction, curb digital addiction, and limit cyberbullying. In the United States, citing a 2023 education policy report, the authors note that roughly two-thirds of states had enacted some form of phone legislation, with remaining states considering similar measures.

Despite this rapid policy shift, large-scale experimental evidence on how classroom phone restrictions affect learning, well-being, and daily behavior has remained scarce. Past observational and quasi-experimental studies have produced mixed results, ranging from academic or well-being improvements among struggling students to little measurable change, while research on classroom laptops indicates that unrestricted device access can impair learning.

Studies conducted across different settings also illustrate how complex the relationship between smartphones and student outcomes can be. For example, an earlier meta-analysis of laboratory tasks found that simply having an idle smartphone in sight had no statistically significant effect on cognitive performance. In real schools, a prior study comparing restrictive and permissive smartphone policies indicated that bans did not meaningfully improve student mental well-being or quality of life, though they were linked to a slight reduction in staff time spent managing phone-related issues.

Free daily newsletter

Don’t miss the next big psychology finding

Every morning, PsyPost sends a short briefing on the most interesting new peer-reviewed research in psychology and neuroscience.

✓ Free ✓ One email a day ✓ Unsubscribe anytime

“Phone bans are among the fastest-spreading education policies in the world. Today, about half of the world’s schools have imposed some phone restrictions,” study co-authors Alp Sungu, an assistant professor of operations, information and decisions at the Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania, and Andreas Bjerre-Nielsen, an associate professor of economics and social data science at the University of Copenhagen, told PsyPost. “Yet, there has been a marked scarcity of causal evidence. Our goal in this research is to provide large-scale, experimental evidence on this policy debate.”

To evaluate the semester-long impact of taking phones out of actual classrooms, Sungu and Bjerre-Nielsen teamed up with Pradeep Kumar Choudhury of Jawaharlal Nehru University in New Delhi to run a randomized controlled trial in Odisha, an eastern Indian state of more than 40 million people. Smartphone ownership among young people aged 15 to 29 in the region exceeds 70 percent, making mobile devices an everyday presence on college campuses.

The preregistered study, whose replication data were posted publicly online, ran throughout the spring 2024 semester from February to May. It included 16,683 students, 742 teachers, and 2,305 courses across 10 higher education institutions, with students averaging 19.4 years of age (ranging from 16 to 22) and 35.5 percent being female.

The researchers commissioned roughly 1,000 wooden phone deposit boxes and installed them in classrooms across all 10 campuses. Because classrooms were frequently shared by different classes, every room received a box, meaning the difference between groups lay strictly in enforcing the ban. A full-time research assistant was stationed at each institution alongside a designated faculty coordinator to oversee the trial.

Rather than randomizing individual students, the researchers divided each institution into department-and-grade units, assigning 198 of 420 units to the phone ban and the rest to a control group. Because randomization occurred at the department and grade level, students in the ban group experienced the same rule across nearly all of their classes throughout the term.

In ban classrooms, the rule was mandatory rather than optional. Teachers required students to place their phones in the wooden deposit box at the start of every lecture, granting exceptions only for documented emergencies or caregiving duties, while students in control departments kept their usual phone access.

The team gathered data from three sources. They obtained official attendance records and end-of-semester grade point averages (GPA) from before and during the trial, which relied mainly on externally written, blindly graded exams taken without technology. They also surveyed a subset of 2,557 students twice during the term about their attitudes, well-being, and digital habits, and had research assistants conduct exploratory random spot checks by briefly observing classrooms through windows or doorways without interrupting lectures.

When accounting for students’ grades from the prior term, students in phone-free classrooms earned higher end-of-semester GPAs than peers in control classrooms. The average gain was 0.073 standard deviations, a statistical measure showing how far scores shifted relative to the typical spread of grades across students. The authors evaluated this overall gain using a one-sided statistical test, which checks only for an effect in one expected direction, and the lower edge of the estimate’s margin of error fell very close to zero.

To put that size in perspective, the authors compared it with established benchmarks in education research. Across randomized education trials overall, meta-analyses find a median gain of roughly 0.10 standard deviations, while large-scale trials typically produce effects around 0.05 standard deviations. Major curriculum reforms and teacher training programs generally yield gains between 0.05 and 0.20 standard deviations, with the yearly difference between an average teacher and a very good teacher sitting near 0.20. The phone ban’s impact sat below the overall education median but above typical large-scale trials, aligning it with other scalable policies rather than transformative reforms.

“The effect sizes on learning outcomes are sizable, but not transformative. Hence, treating phone bans as a silver bullet to the challenges in education will be misleading,” the researchers explained. “However, it’s potentially a low-cost intervention and it helps students who might need it the most.”

Subgroup analyses indicated that these academic gains were not distributed evenly. Improvements were concentrated among students who began the term with below-median grades and among first-year undergraduates, with a marginal gain appearing among students outside science, technology, engineering, and mathematics (STEM) fields. For students with above-median prior grades, postgraduate students, and STEM majors, differences between ban and control classrooms were close to zero and not statistically significant.

The researchers also looked at how grades were distributed across students. While the overall spread of grades widened over the semester in both groups, it expanded less sharply in phone-free classrooms. Grades also became less clustered around a narrow set of scores, a pattern the authors describe as lower grade concentration rather than a direct measure of inequality on its own. Across student rankings, peers in phone-free classes tended to score higher through most of the distribution, with the largest advantage appearing among lower-ranked learners.

To check whether students simply started showing up to class more often, the authors also examined overall and course-level attendance records. Across all analyses, there was no consistent evidence that the phone ban changed student attendance, pointing instead toward shifts in classroom attention and behavior rather than higher attendance.

These academic findings align with an earlier classroom-style experiment, which found that students who kept cell phones in their possession, felt higher anxiety about being without a phone, or faced text-message distractions scored lower on a comprehension quiz, with impairment peaking 10 to 15 minutes into class. That earlier study evaluated short-term recall after a brief simulated lecture rather than semester-long exam performance in real university courses, yet both lines of evidence indicate that phone access can interfere with learning.

In the survey of 2,557 students, experiencing the classroom ban shifted attitudes in favor of phone restrictions. Compared to control peers, students in phone-free courses became more supportive of classroom bans and more likely to view them as beneficial. When asked to choose among five policy options ranging from full-day bans and lecture-only bans to phone-allowed zones, app limits, or no restrictions, treated students were noticeably less likely to select the no-ban option, with preferences shifting most toward full-day bans.

Support for the ban and perceived benefits were stronger among female students and among more engaged learners who tend to sit near the front of the room. Although lower-performing students gained the most academically, more motivated students expressed stronger preference for the rule, which the authors suggest may happen because a quieter, more focused classroom environment feels more noticeable to them.

Across several broader measures of student experience, differences between the ban and control groups were not statistically significant, including perceived distraction, perceived learning, subjective well-being, academic motivation, total phone use, frequency of bringing phones to campus, and online harassment. Treated students did report a mild uptick in fear of missing out alongside a slight dip in using other electronic devices during lectures. Among male students specifically, those in ban classrooms reported small increases in fear of missing out, overall screen time, and perceived distraction relative to male students in control classes.

The exploratory classroom spot checks pointed to calmer learning environments. Students in phone-free classrooms exhibited fewer disruptive behaviors and less off-topic conversation with peers, while teachers appeared more engaged with teaching materials and busier maintaining focus. The authors note that this added teacher activity does not indicate classroom disorder and may partly reflect the work of enforcing the ban itself, though even without being subject to the rule, teachers in ban classrooms cut back on their own in-class phone use.

“We expected students to resent it. Observing an increase in support for the policy was a surprise,” the researchers noted. “Also, we find a drop in teachers’ occasional use of their phones during the class and they appeared more engaged with their lectures!”

In one unexpected pattern, outside observers actually rated students in phone-free rooms as appearing more distracted than students in control classrooms. In the authors’ interpretation, removing a quiet source of self-distraction like a smartphone may prompt students to redirect their attention toward ambient noise or surrounding activity that is easier for an observer looking through a window to spot.

Looking at potential mechanisms behind the grade gains, the authors propose that removing phones may free up working memory for deeper processing of lecture material while acting as a commitment tool that helps students resist short-term digital temptations. They also note that biased teacher grading is unlikely to account for the gains, since 60 to 80 percent of each course grade under Odisha’s centralized assessment system comes from externally written, blind-graded exams. Notably, the gains that did emerge by field appeared in non-STEM courses, where external exams make up 80 percent of final marks and instructors have the least grading discretion.

There are a few caveats to keep in mind when interpreting these findings. The trial took place at higher education institutions in eastern India, where students are already academically selected, whereas much of the current policy debate centers on primary and secondary schools. Because first-year and lower-performing students benefited most, the authors suggest impacts might be stronger in younger grades, though direct experiments in those settings are still needed, and results could differ in wealthier countries where students frequently bring laptops, tablets, or smartwatches into class.

The timing of the restriction also shapes what the study can tell us. Because students only stored their phones during lectures and regained them between classes, the experiment does not measure the effects of full-day, bell-to-bell bans, which could influence peer socializing, well-being, or daily digital habits differently.

Finally, two measurement limits bear on the results. Because the researchers lacked data linking individual teachers to specific courses, they could not completely rule out subtle shifts in the smaller internal portion of course grades. In addition, the classroom spot checks were exploratory, and although observers were not told which rooms had the ban, they could infer it simply by seeing whether phones were out on desks or placed inside the wooden boxes.

“The most likely misreading is that ‘screens are the enemy.’ They often have numerous harms, and benefits, which are beyond the scope of our study,” the researchers cautioned. “Non-productive, potentially distracting, phone use during a lecture can reduce students’ academic performance. That does not mean a well-designed educational technology will cause harm.”

Looking ahead, the team hopes to examine broader school-wide restrictions alongside newer classroom debates over artificial intelligence (AI), as some schools and governments begin limiting student access to AI tools over concerns about learning and distraction.

“Bell-to-bell bans and studying younger populations are very important. For instance, we detect no impact on well-being or cyberbullying, where these socially relevant effects might emerge beyond classrooms — at school cafeterias or corridors,” the researchers said. “Also, governments have started to ban AI in classrooms. There is some research that shows its harms, yet the policy discourse on classroom bans of educationally tailored AI needs more scientific evidence.”

The study, “Phones impede learning: Evidence from a massive phone-free classroom experiment,” was authored by Alp Sungu, Pradeep Kumar Choudhury, and Andreas Bjerre-Nielsen.

TweetSendScanShareSendPinShareShareShareShareShare

Follow PsyPost

The latest research, however you prefer to read it.

Daily newsletter

One email a day. The newest research, nothing else.

Google News

Get PsyPost stories in your Google News feed.

Add PsyPost to Google News
RSS feed

Use your favorite reader.

Copy RSS URL
Social media
Support independent science journalism

Ad-free reading, full archives, and weekly deep dives for members.

Become a member

Trending

  • Parents who spank are more likely to hit a child out of anger years later, study finds
  • Psychologists find a hidden asymmetry in how people judge potential partners
  • Men and women mostly agree on gender roles, except for one surprising area
  • New psychology study suggests your sexual turn-ons are far more fluid than assumed
  • Past experiences with classical music predict a taste for sophisticated genres

Science of Money

  • Six studies reveal the trust penalty of using AI on the job
  • How cash holdings predicted stock survival during the COVID-19 crash
  • How trade policy uncertainty drives corporate greenwashing
  • What psychology reveals about how founders dial startup obsession up or down
  • New study reveals what actually predicts livestream shopping sales

Recent

  • How brain cell networks expand and shrink as cocaine habits form
  • New study finds bosses who share stories about their own good deeds risk disgusting employees
  • College students who spend more time in intense physical activity report slightly fewer depressive symptoms
  • Parents who spank are more likely to hit a child out of anger years later, study finds
  • People judge larger bodies as more forgiving, study suggests
  • Even when calories and nutrients match, ultraprocessed foods trigger a larger insulin surge
  • Evolutionary hypothesis linking facial symmetry to women’s mating behavior fails to hold up in new study
  • People with ADHD have higher odds of a wide range of gut symptoms, study finds
  • Psychologists find a hidden asymmetry in how people judge potential partners
  • Criticism from Tucker Carlson and Joe Rogan cut Trump’s sway over Republicans in half in experiment on the Epstein files

PsyPost is a psychology and neuroscience news website dedicated to reporting the latest research on human behavior, cognition, and society. (READ MORE...)

  • Mental Health
  • Neuroimaging
  • Personality Psychology
  • Social Psychology
  • Artificial Intelligence
  • Cognitive Science
  • Psychopharmacology
  • Contact us
  • Disclaimer
  • Privacy policy
  • Terms and conditions
  • FAQ
  • Jobs

(c) PsyPost Media Inc

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist

Subscribe
  • My Account
  • Cognitive Science Research
  • Mental Health Research
  • Social Psychology Research
  • Drug Research
  • Relationship Research
  • About PsyPost
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy

(c) PsyPost Media Inc