PsyPost
  • Mental Health
  • Social Psychology
  • Cognitive Science
  • Neuroscience
  • About
No Result
View All Result
Join
My Account
PsyPost
No Result
View All Result
Home Exclusive Social Psychology Sexism

Men and women mostly agree on gender roles, except for one surprising area

by Eric W. Dolan
November 20, 2026
Reading Time: 10 mins read
[Adobe Stock]

[Adobe Stock]

Add as a preferred source on GoogleFollow on Google News

A new psychological measurement tool allows scientists to assess what people believe men and women should do at work and at home without forcing those expectations into an either-or tradeoff. Developed and validated in a study published in Sex Roles, the new scales measure beliefs about caregiving and career roles separately for each gender on an identical rating scale. Initial testing indicates that the tool performs consistently across male and female respondents and predicts attitudes such as feminist identity and willingness to confront everyday sexism better than an established alternative.

Prescriptive gender role beliefs are ideas about how men and women ought to behave and which responsibilities should fall to each gender in daily life. In the United States, gender continues to shape how people divide their time, even though 91% of Americans report that gender equality is very important. Women make up nearly half of the workforce, yet national time-use data show they spend an average of 40 minutes more per day than men on household chores like cooking and cleaning, while working men in heterosexual couples enjoy two more hours of leisure time each week, a gap that widens to four and a half hours among parents of young children.

Measuring how people think about these roles has proven surprisingly difficult. A 1990 handbook cataloged 235 measures related to gender roles, yet many existing questionnaires rely on dated phrasing, such as asking whether it is ridiculous for a woman to run a locomotive or for a man to darn socks, which nearly everyone now rejects. Survey wording can also distort how egalitarian people appear: a 2026 European survey study found that when respondents were given separate options for equality, traditionalism, and role reversal on political leadership, nearly half of those classified as traditionalists under a conventional survey item actually endorsed gender equality.

Existing tools also tend to bundle men’s and women’s roles together, treating home and career duties as a zero-sum competition in which one gender’s gain must be the other’s loss. How questions frame comparisons between genders can itself sway responses, as shown in a 2022 study of parenthood norms where participants endorsed stronger parenting expectations for women when evaluating both genders back to back, but favored their own gender on the first question alone.

Free daily newsletter

Don’t miss the next big psychology finding

Every morning, PsyPost sends a short briefing on the most interesting new peer-reviewed research in psychology and neuroscience.

✓ Free ✓ One email a day ✓ Unsubscribe anytime

In addition, older questionnaires rarely underwent tests of measurement invariance, a statistical check confirming that a survey measures the same underlying idea in the same way across groups such as men and women. A 2025 analysis of published psychology studies found that only 4% of group comparisons reported achieving invariance, none of them reproducible, and only 25% met the strictest standard when the reviewers ran the tests themselves.

To overcome these measurement hurdles, Samantha B. Douglas and her colleagues at the University of Florida and Wilfrid Laurier University set out to create the Breadmakers and Breadwinners Prescriptive Gender Role Beliefs Scales. The project grew out of an unexpected pattern in research on unconscious mental associations.

“This work was led by Samantha Douglas, who was one of my graduate students at the time,” corresponding author Colin Tucker Smith, who worked on the project while at the University of Florida and is now an assistant professor of psychology at Wilfrid Laurier University and chair of the scientific advisory board for Project Implicit, told PsyPost on behalf of the team.

“At first, we were trying to understand this odd finding from implicit social cognition in which women showed more stereotypic associations on an Implicit Association Test (IAT) between gender and career (vs. family) than did men. Usually we find that men are more likely to show stronger biases in line with the cultural norm, so I was interested in that and Samantha was starting her graduate career and interested in researching gender, so we worked on this puzzle for quite a while.”

An Implicit Association Test is a timed computer sorting task used in psychology to gauge automatic mental links between concepts, such as pairing gender categories with words about work or family. Hoping to see how those automatic associations compared with people’s conscious beliefs, the researchers looked for an existing survey that could isolate each gender-and-role pairing on its own.

“What Samantha quickly found is that, even though there is a wealth of self-report measures of gender roles, she could not find a single one that did what we needed to do,” Smith explained. “I don’t want to get too into the weeds, but on an IAT, there are four relationships at play. In this specific case, the effect could be driven by a difference between men and women in the strength of the pairing of 1) women + career, 2) men + family, 3) women + family, or 4) men + career.”

“But every measure of gender roles conflated at least two of these roles,” he continued. “In other words, they ask questions like, ‘It’s more reasonable for a woman to stay home and take care of the kids than for a man to do that’ or ‘It is more difficult for a man to choose between his family and his career.’ We really wanted to get at each of these elements separately, so Samantha set about doing that for her master’s work.”

Before running the main validation study, the researchers refined the questionnaire across seven pilot studies involving 4,693 participants, narrowing an initial pool of 94 items down to two parallel 12-item scales. One version asks about men and the other asks about women, using identical wording aside from gender pronouns. Each version splits into two six-item subscales: a caregiving and homemaking subscale covering tasks like childcare, cooking, and keeping a welcoming home, and a career and home maintenance subscale covering earning income, handling finances, home repairs, and keeping the family safe.

Respondents rate how important each duty is to being a man or a woman, such as “An important part of being a man is taking responsibility for childcare,” on a scale from 1 (not at all important) to 7 (extremely important). To test the scales, the authors conducted an online study in which recruitment quotas, model-fit indices, and validity thresholds were preregistered in advance. They also posted the study’s data, analytic code, and materials publicly on the Open Science Framework.

In total, 375 U.S. adults completed the survey, averaging about 43 years old, with 51% identifying as women and 47% as men. Six respondents reported other gender identities, 72% identified as White, and the sample averaged politically moderate after being recruited to balance liberals and conservatives. After answering demographic questions, everyone completed both versions of the new scales in randomized order alongside established questionnaires measuring social roles, benevolent and hostile sexism, social dominance orientation, feminist identity, and, for women, willingness to speak up against everyday sexism.

Statistical checks on the 372 participants who answered every item supported the intended two-part structure of family and career roles for both scales across most traditional measures of model fit. However, one standard index of model error indicated marginal fit for both versions, and chi-square tests, which the authors describe as overly conservative, indicated poor fit.

The researchers also tested measurement invariance between men and women across three progressively stricter levels, checking whether both groups organized the items the same way, weighted them similarly, and used the rating scale from the same baseline. Both scales met established benchmarks for changes in fit across all three levels, achieving what is known as scalar invariance. Still, the baseline fit indices hovered around conventional acceptability cutoffs and sat just below the usual benchmark for the men’s scale. Overall, the findings provide evidence that score differences between male and female respondents reflect genuine differences in beliefs rather than differences in how the two groups interpret the questions.

Next, the authors evaluated how the four subscales aligned with existing measures of gender attitudes and sexism, using criteria they had preregistered in advance for both convergent and discriminant validity. Overall, correlations supported convergent validity with the Social Roles Questionnaire and the Ambivalent Sexism Inventory, although not every individual correlation reached the threshold the authors set. When all four subscales were analyzed together to isolate each one’s unique contribution, expecting men to focus on careers and women to focus on family was tied to traditional scores on the Social Roles Questionnaire and to higher benevolent sexism, which refers to protective yet patronizing views of women.

By contrast, hostile sexism was uniquely related only to expecting women to take on family duties. Simple one-on-one correlations had initially suggested a puzzling positive link between benevolent sexism and nontraditional beliefs, such as expecting men to be caregivers or women to focus on careers, but those links disappeared once all four subscales were evaluated together, illustrating why measuring each belief separately matters. Meanwhile, connections between the new scales and a general preference for group hierarchy, known as social dominance orientation, stayed below the authors’ preregistered cutoff, indicating that the tool captures beliefs about gender roles rather than broader attitudes toward dominance.

Among women in the sample (including one trans-woman), the four subscales together also predicted both how strongly respondents identified as feminists and how willing they were to intervene in everyday sexist scenarios, such as speaking up when a waiter hands a restaurant bill to a male friend instead of to them. Even after accounting for scores on the established Social Roles Questionnaire, the new scales continued to predict both outcomes.

Breaking those results down by subscale highlighted patterns that older, all-in-one questionnaires can obscure. Among women, the single strongest predictor of identifying as a feminist was lower agreement that providing income and safety is an essential part of being a man, alongside stronger support for women’s career roles and men’s family roles, whereas the Social Roles Questionnaire subscales did not show statistically significant links once the new scales were included.

For willingness to confront everyday sexism, views on career and provider duties for both men and women remained tied to speaking up even alongside the older survey, while beliefs about women’s family roles did not show a statistically significant unique link with either outcome. The authors suggest that beliefs about work and financial roles may stand out because people often picture workplaces rather than home life when imagining sexist encounters.

In an exploratory analysis that was not preregistered, the team also compared scores across gender, age, and political orientation. Among the 369 participants who identified as men or women, differences on three of the four subscales were not statistically significant. On expectations for men in caregiving and homemaking, however, men scored modestly higher than women, averaging 5.42 compared with 4.99 on the 7-point scale. The authors note that previous studies suggest men tend to overestimate how much housework they actually do, leaving open whether men overstate how much they value the role or simply fall short of practicing it.

Participant age did not show a statistically significant relationship with any of the four subscales. More politically conservative respondents tended to endorse breadwinner roles for men and caregiving roles for women more strongly, whereas links between political views and nontraditional expectations for men at home or women at work were not statistically significant.

“I think the thing that I’m still puzzling over is that men were more likely than women to say that taking care of the family and home is an important part of being a man,” Smith said. “I’m not exactly sure what to make of that. In some sense, it makes me hopeful (as a person who thinks caring for one’s family should be an important part of a man’s identity).”

“I also wonder if men are being truthful,” he added. “And then it also brings me back to the original motivation for creating this scale and pushes me to collect some data comparing this scale to the Gender-Career IAT in an organized way.”

More broadly, the authors argue that separating men’s and women’s home and work expectations allows social scientists to test theories without assuming that domestic and career responsibilities are locked in competition. At a societal level, they also note that measuring these four beliefs independently could help researchers track whether views on men’s caregiving or women’s careers shift at different rates over time.

“It’s a scale construction paper, so this is stepping away from the data slightly, but from the standpoint of the theoretical motivation for the scale, I would say that I am hoping the average person takes away from this work that gender roles are not a zero-sum game,” Smith noted. “I mean, yes, in any couple, someone has to cook the dinner and someone has to take out the trash. And, if they are not independently wealthy, one or more of them needs to get up and go to work most days.”

“But what doesn’t have to happen is pinning those tasks consistently to a specific gender,” he emphasized. “And further, whether you think it’s important for men or women to care about their family should be considered wholly independently from whether it’s important that they identify with their career.”

Beyond academic research, the authors propose that the scales could serve as a practical tool for couples and relationship counselors. Research links perceived unfairness in how household labor is divided to lower relationship satisfaction, so having partners complete the scales independently could help surface mismatched expectations about childcare, chores, and finances. More generally, even though the paper focuses on validating a measurement tool rather than tracking large behavioral shifts, Smith highlighted everyday settings where examining gender role expectations matters.

“I don’t think effect sizes are highly relevant here, but I do think the scale has practical significance,” he pointed out. “I think it’s important for people to consider their views on gender roles. This is true in work settings – who is expected to take notes at meetings, bring in food to potlucks, send around a sympathy card, etc.? And also in home settings given that differential expectations around gender role expectations seem like a surefire recipe for unhappy relationships.”

As with all research, there are some caveats to consider. Although the new scales avoid building heterosexual two-parent partnerships directly into the questions, the items still focus on home and career tasks tied to a particular lifestyle and life stage, such as raising children and working a wage-paying job, leaving out expectations in other areas of life and outside a binary view of gender.

“We do mention this in the paper, but no scale is the ‘one true scale,'” Smith remarked. “This scale does a couple of things that I’m not wild about. One, it reinforces a gender binary in referring to men and women and not asking questions about other experiences of gender.”

“Further, it situates gender roles in a somewhat stereotypical space – sort of a middle-class existence with a home to care for that includes children and a wage-paying job to go to,” he added. “Our decision was, rather than trying to capture the entirety of experiences, we would focus on the most common ones with the idea that they’re the most impactful (in that they’re the most common). But certainly, the scale misses the lived experiences of lots of people and we wouldn’t want anyone to think otherwise.”

Looking ahead, the authors point out that survey items referring generically to “men” and “women” are often assumed to describe White people, making it important to test how prescriptive gender expectations shift across racial, cultural, and other identities. While the scale’s simple phrasing can easily be modified to ask about specific groups, the researchers caution that any adapted version would need to be validated on its own before being put into practice.

“I really hope that this measure gets used,” Smith said. “I have a sense that the most likely way to make that happen is to show its usefulness myself, so I would like to do some next steps work on it soon.”

“I also think, as we allude to in the Discussion section, that the measure is highly adaptable to different groups,” he noted. “In other words, the scale is about men and women without any other demographic information. I think an obvious next step will be to look at whether there are differences in perceived gender roles if we start specifying the group. Might we see that, for example, there are differences in the extent to which people see caring for one’s family as an important part of being a man if that man is described as being ‘a middle-aged man,’ ‘a Black man,’ ‘a gay man,’ ‘a Republican man,’ et cetera?”

The study, “Breadmakers and Breadwinners: Measuring Prescriptive Gender Role Beliefs for Men and Women Separately and on a Common Metric,” was authored by Samantha B. Douglas, Colin Tucker Smith, and Gregory D. Webster.

TweetSendScanShareSendPinShareShareShareShareShare

Follow PsyPost

The latest research, however you prefer to read it.

Daily newsletter

One email a day. The newest research, nothing else.

Google News

Get PsyPost stories in your Google News feed.

Add PsyPost to Google News
RSS feed

Use your favorite reader.

Copy RSS URL
Social media
Support independent science journalism

Ad-free reading, full archives, and weekly deep dives for members.

Become a member

Trending

  • Past experiences with classical music predict a taste for sophisticated genres
  • New research finds high testosterone does not impair men’s emotional reframing
  • Psychedelics trigger a bizarre memory paradox that makes the unknown feel like home
  • Musically trained children score higher on tests of intelligence, working memory, and reading
  • Republicans experience worse mental health in Democratic neighborhoods, study finds

Science of Money

  • How trade policy uncertainty drives corporate greenwashing
  • What psychology reveals about how founders dial startup obsession up or down
  • New study reveals what actually predicts livestream shopping sales
  • How eating a product today shapes which brand you buy tomorrow
  • The psychology of buying clothes you haven’t seen

Recent

  • Acceptance and commitment therapy linked to neural shifts in the depressed brain
  • Neuroimaging study links heightened sensitivity to peer rejection with harsher parenting after childhood abuse
  • Reanalysis of 1950s LSD experiments challenges the idea that psychedelics make art more creative
  • Common classroom accommodations for ADHD fail to improve student behavior or schoolwork in clinical trial
  • Why stopping SSRIs can cause anxiety: A rebound in serotonin neuron activity may play a role
  • Focused ultrasound aimed deep into the brain may ease delusions, pilot study suggests
  • Mindfulness therapy alters brain waves in major depressive disorder
  • Daily peanut consumption may improve brain insulin responsiveness in older adults
  • GLP-1 drugs linked to reduced alcohol use and healthier eating in real-world study
  • Heavy cannabis use linked to mild psychotic symptoms and depressive thoughts

PsyPost is a psychology and neuroscience news website dedicated to reporting the latest research on human behavior, cognition, and society. (READ MORE...)

  • Mental Health
  • Neuroimaging
  • Personality Psychology
  • Social Psychology
  • Artificial Intelligence
  • Cognitive Science
  • Psychopharmacology
  • Contact us
  • Disclaimer
  • Privacy policy
  • Terms and conditions
  • FAQ
  • Jobs

(c) PsyPost Media Inc

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist

Subscribe
  • My Account
  • Cognitive Science Research
  • Mental Health Research
  • Social Psychology Research
  • Drug Research
  • Relationship Research
  • About PsyPost
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy

(c) PsyPost Media Inc