Adults who are more outgoing, cooperative, and emotionally stable tend to have slightly more biological children, according to a cross-cultural survey of more than 15,000 people across Canada, the United States, and Japan. Published in Culture and Evolution, the research also indicates that how personality relates to family size depends on national culture alongside major demographic factors such as marriage and age.
Psychologists commonly organize human personality using a framework known as the Big Five, which measures where individuals fall along five broad spectrums of thought, feeling, and behavior. Openness to experience reflects curiosity and receptivity to new ideas, conscientiousness captures organization and self-discipline, extraversion describes sociability and assertiveness, agreeableness involves warmth and cooperation, and neuroticism refers to a tendency toward anxiety, moodiness, and emotional distress. In evolutionary psychology, researchers examine how traits like these relate to reproductive success, defined concretely as the number of biological children a person has.
Personality shapes how people find romantic partners and maintain long-term relationships, which in turn can affect family size. Warmth and dependability tend to foster supportive partnerships, whereas high anxiety and emotional reactivity are linked to relationship strain and lower sexual satisfaction. In Western populations, a 2011 study of more than 15,700 American adults found that both men and women who scored higher in extraversion and openness and lower in neuroticism had more children. Higher agreeableness and lower conscientiousness, meanwhile, predicted larger families among women only.
Fertility and personality patterns also vary by region within a single nation, with a 2021 state-level study in the United States indicating that regional personality differences corresponded with local birth rates and the timing of parenthood. Less was known about whether the same personality traits predict family size across industrialized countries with contrasting cultural traditions, such as individualistic North American societies versus more collectivist East Asian societies. Average personality profiles vary across borders; a 2007 survey spanning 56 nations ranked the United States highest on extraversion, agreeableness, conscientiousness, and openness, followed by Canada and then Japan, with the order reversed for neuroticism.
Don’t miss the next big psychology finding
Every morning, PsyPost sends a short briefing on the most interesting new peer-reviewed research in psychology and neuroscience.
To examine whether links between personality and childbearing hold across different industrialized cultures, lead author Maryanne L. Fisher, a professor of psychology and the Santamarian Research Chair in Science at Saint Mary’s University in Halifax, Nova Scotia, compared adults in Canada, the United States, and Japan alongside her colleagues. The researchers hypothesized that higher extraversion, agreeableness, conscientiousness, and openness, paired with lower neuroticism, would be associated with having more biological children. Drawing on prior work suggesting that personality differences between men and women widen in more gender-equal nations, the team also predicted that women would score higher than men across all five traits to a greater degree in Canada than in the United States or Japan.
“Most of what we knew about personality and family size came from American samples,” Fisher, who is also the author of the 2026 Oxford University Press book “Evolutionary Psychology: A Very Short Introduction,” told PsyPost. “I wanted to see whether earlier identified patterns held up in countries with different cultural values. Japan was a useful contrast to Canada and the USA, given its much lower birth rate. We were fortunate to obtain an unusually large dataset of more than 15,000 adults across the three countries, collected by Hidenori Komatsu as part of a larger survey project.”
The researchers designed the measures and hired a survey company to distribute the questionnaires and collect responses between February and March 2022, with Komatsu, a study co-author at the Central Research Institute of Electric Power Industry in Tokyo, leading data collection. The final sample totaled 15,120 registered adult users aged 20 or older, matching the highest legal threshold for adulthood among the three nations at the time. Within each country, the 5,040 respondents were divided equally between men and women across five age brackets spanning people in their 20s, 30s, 40s, 50s, and 60s or older.
The personality and family questions were embedded inside a broader online survey investigating public health habits and attitudes toward COVID-19 vaccination. Respondents in Japan completed the survey in Japanese, while those in the United States and Canada completed it in English, with Canadians offered a French option that none selected. Alongside questions about age, sex, marital status, and the sex of their spouse, participants completed a brief 10-item questionnaire assessing the Big Five personality traits and reported their total number of biological children.
When the authors analyzed the data, basic demographic characteristics accounted for about 21 percent of the variation in how many children participants had. Being married, female, older, and in a heterosexual marriage were all associated with having more biological children. Country of residence also mattered, with respondents in the United States and Canada reporting more children than those in Japan. That gap aligns with national birth rate estimates cited by the authors of 12.2 births per 1,000 people in the United States, 10 in Canada, and 6.9 in Japan.
Adding the Big Five traits in a second step improved the model statistically, yet total explained variation remained at roughly 21 percent, indicating that personality added little beyond what demographics already accounted for. Across the combined sample, participants who scored higher on extraversion and agreeableness tended to have slightly more biological children, whereas those who scored higher on neuroticism tended to have slightly fewer. Associations between family size and both conscientiousness and openness to experience were not statistically significant.
“The effects are small but important,” Fisher explained. “Personally, I think of personality here as being one of several factors that relate to one’s number of children. I definitely would discourage thinking of it as predicting the outcome of any individual’s family size until further work is done.”
Statistical tests examining whether country of residence modified these patterns indicated that the relationship between personality and childbearing was not identical across the three nations. Even after adjusting for relationship status and sex, how all five personality dimensions related to offspring counts varied depending on which country a person lived in. Overall personality averages in Canada and the United States closely resembled one another, while scores in Japan stood apart from both North American samples.
The team’s prediction regarding sex differences and national gender equality was not supported by the data. Japan and the United States showed a consistent pattern: men scored higher than women on extraversion and agreeableness, women scored higher on neuroticism and openness, and differences in conscientiousness were not statistically significant. Canada showed a slightly different pattern rather than the across-the-board female advantage the authors had predicted. Canadian men scored higher than Canadian women on extraversion, agreeableness, and conscientiousness, while women scored higher only on neuroticism, and the difference in openness was not statistically significant.
Several of the main fertility patterns align with an earlier longitudinal study of parenthood expectations, which found that adults who consistently expected to become parents scored higher on extraversion and agreeableness, with men in that group also showing lower neuroticism. That earlier work tracked people’s expectations and intentions of becoming parents over time, however, whereas the new study measured the actual number of biological children participants had.
At the same time, the null finding for conscientiousness stands in tension with an international study of personality and biological children, which identified conscientiousness as the most consistent positive predictor of family size across countries. The results also diverge from a study of older Serbian adults that linked higher emotionality to having more children and higher openness to having fewer, though that research evaluated one national group using a six-factor personality model rather than the Big Five inventory across multiple cultures.
To explain why conscientiousness did not show an overall link to family size in their sample, the authors point to competing behavioral tendencies. Highly conscientious people may attract partners more easily, the researchers propose, yet they may also use birth control more consistently or postpone parenthood until they feel financially secure. Earlier research linking openness to larger families included a higher share of unmarried adults, for whom traits tied to exploring new social relationships may play a bigger role.
“I expected openness to matter, because prior work found that more open people had more children,” Fisher said. “We found no such link. One possible reason is that many of our participants were married and not looking for partners. Another reason is that maybe openness is really not all that important; further work is absolutely needed.”
“The sex differences in Canada also caught me off guard,” Fisher added. “Canada ranks highest of the three countries on gender equality, and earlier work led us to expect women here (I am Canadian) would score higher than men on all five personality traits.”
Regarding those unexpected sex differences in personality, the authors argue that national gender-equality rankings, which emphasize economic and political participation, do not translate linearly into shifts in everyday social roles or self-descriptions. From an evolutionary perspective, the researchers suggest that cross-cultural variation in how personality relates to childbearing helps explain why humans have not evolved a single uniform personality profile. Because local social and economic conditions shift which traits favor starting a family, diverse personalities continue to persist across populations.
There are a few things to keep in mind. Because personality and family size were measured at a single point in time, the data cannot show whether personality traits lead people to become parents or whether the demands and rewards of raising children gradually reshape a person’s sociability, warmth, and stress levels. Demographic realities like marriage, age, and country of residence also dwarfed personality in explaining who had children.
“I think it is always a good idea to remind readers that this type of work relies on correlations and self-report,” Fisher cautioned. “Here we use correlations from a single survey, and they do not show that personality causes anyone to have more or fewer children. Many of our younger participants may well go on to have more children. We also measured personality with a brief ten-item scale, and everyone self-reported, which we know may introduce bias.”
That 10-question personality measure, embedded in a pandemic-era public health survey, captures broad tendencies with just two items per trait and cannot tease apart narrower personality facets. Nor did the survey distinguish between planned and unplanned pregnancies, fertility difficulties, or deliberate decisions to remain childfree. Future longitudinal studies could track how narrower personality traits interact with economic pressures and personal values, such as choosing not to have children out of concern for climate change, to shape family decisions over time.
“I would really like to do some more research on gender equality and number of children, specifically,” Fisher noted. “I have been interested in population decline and women’s competition for mates in light of perceived quality of potential mates. Based on the current study, I would expect women’s decisions about having children to include personality factors, but also vary according to how free and capable they feel in making reproductive decisions.”
The study, “How many? The Big Five and the number of children across three cultures,” was authored by Maryanne L. Fisher, T. Joel Wade, Hidenori Komatsu, Nobuyuki Tanaka, Hiromi Kubota, Rebecca Burch, Catherine Salmon, and David Widman.